0 Members and 1 Guest are viewing this topic.
Quote from: the vicar on April 17, 2018, 10:17:01 pmSimple 1 penalty from a tackle that should of never been made 2 a stupid own goal and 3 a terrible officials not giving a wasnt offside
Simple 1 penalty from a tackle that should of never been made 2 a stupid own goal and 3 a terrible officials not giving a
Miles off! I was in line behind the linno
Anyone who thinks that the scored of the third goal wasn’t offside doesn’t know the offside rule.From my seat in the South Stand my first reaction was offside.Even the player who scored had two looks across to the linesman to see if he had got away with it.However, even taking that into consideration, we should not have dropped points last night.Bury are a very poor team and we were saying that the only way they would get anything from the game would be if we gave them something.Mason was unlucky, if he hadn’t headed the ball then their 19 would have scored.Blair seemed unaware that the player he eventually tripped was making the run behind him, maybe because he isn’t a natural RB.Still, another game and another point.Nine draws now in the last eighteen league games.Are we in form?Results are mediocre reallyYes only three defeats in 18 but also only 6 wins.
come off it Hound, you were sat in the South and thought he was offside in front of the North? I sit in the West and was in 2 minds but my gut instinct was offside, I even watched the highlights in slow mo and to me it confirmed he was offside but not by as much as some including DF seem to think.
are you basing that on your view last night or after watching the highlights, try watching the highlights in slow mo he was probably a yard off when the ball was played
Quote from: ravenrover on April 18, 2018, 02:33:48 pmcome off it Hound, you were sat in the South and thought he was offside in front of the North? I sit in the West and was in 2 minds but my gut instinct was offside, I even watched the highlights in slow mo and to me it confirmed he was offside but not by as much as some including DF seem to think.As god is my witness, I called it as offside.It was so blatant.No even, was it or wasn’t it.It should have been the easiest decision of the night for the officials.The scorer even looked across to the Lino twice to see whether he had got away with it.I have now looked at the highlights and it is probably two yards offside.
Quote from: rtid88 on April 17, 2018, 10:47:27 pmIn that still shot the goalscorer is in front of the player with the ball, and at best level with Marosi, to be onside another Rovers player needed to be at least level with Marosi. The nearest defender to that is slightly behind the player with the ball, it's offside by about 3 yards, it's as clear as day
So here's a clearer picture of the exact moment the ball was played (screenshotted youtube at 0.25 speed).We're fortunate with this view that one of the Rugby (American Football?) lines runs straight across the 12 yard mark and you can clearly see the following:- The original shooter is on the line- Butler is about a yard behind the line- The scorer is about a yard in front of the line Offside all day long.For what it's worth, I also think the penalty was a dive having viewed the video in slow-mo a couple of times, but Blair was naive to stick his foot out in the first place. Made it easy for their guy to fall over.
Quote from: Superspy on April 18, 2018, 06:22:49 pmSo here's a clearer picture of the exact moment the ball was played (screenshotted youtube at 0.25 speed).We're fortunate with this view that one of the Rugby (American Football?) lines runs straight across the 12 yard mark and you can clearly see the following:- The original shooter is on the line- Butler is about a yard behind the line- The scorer is about a yard in front of the line Offside all day long.For what it's worth, I also think the penalty was a dive having viewed the video in slow-mo a couple of times, but Blair was naive to stick his foot out in the first place. Made it easy for their guy to fall over.see to me both there players look level ahead of the so called line or the scorer and the ball and butler on it
Lord above donnievic, I can't really say more than the last couple of guys have, but here's the video for yourself. It's been set to play from the right point, all you have to do is hit the cog in the bottom right and slow the speed down to 0.25. It's plain as day that Butler is a good yard short of the "so called" (what?) line when the ball is first played.https://youtu.be/snDVrOYWvZ0?t=87