0 Members and 1 Guest are viewing this topic.
Quote from: bpoolrover on July 17, 2018, 09:00:06 amAlso say there was 3 options and 29 percent voted for a hard brexit 31 for a soft brexit and 40 percent for no brexit who would win?I presume if you used the model Justine Greening is proposing you would then count second preferences, suitably weighted. Although it might not produce anything more convincing than your scenario.That is the difficulty with a second referendum. It may well produce a different result to the first one, but the numbers might not be all that different. Anyone for another 52/48 split?
Also say there was 3 options and 29 percent voted for a hard brexit 31 for a soft brexit and 40 percent for no brexit who would win?
In a lot of the areas that voted leave people are on benefits,people then say they will be worse off but it's not true, they will be no better off de no worse off nothing will change, what would you say to them to get them to change there vote? In certain areas like Blackpool south many jobs are taken up by polish ect. Who come to Blackpool for the season then go home in winter, why will voting remain benefit them?
I'm going off what Justine greening said, have 3 options soft brexit hard brexit remain, I think that's what the idea was unless I'm mistaken
For me that would not be fair thou as the only 2 outcomes could be a remain or asoft brexit and as no1 can agree on a soft brexit it would be better a straight in or out that way there can be none of this you don't no what you voted for
I think so but you can correct me, you would vote for what you want then make a second choice? So remainers would vote no leave and as a second choice vote soft brexit I could be wrong and am sure you will correct me
The soft brexit is not going to work as no1 can agree on it so I don't see the need for it, remainers have long said that people didn't no what they were voting for, have a simpleVote in or out, Surely you would be happy with that compared to where we are now?
Going by what you have said as we have already had the vote people either want aSoft brexit or a no deal or does that not count because it does not suit you
I personally would go hard brexit simply for the fact that there not going to agree on anything, if could they did then I would be open to changing my mind