0 Members and 3 Guests are viewing this topic.
No comment on the verdict on the shooting down of the plane?
Quote from: ravenrover on November 19, 2022, 05:22:26 pmNo comment on the verdict on the shooting down of the plane?Is that one shot down recently or the Malaysian one I commented on twice above?
Quote from: Bristol Red Rover on November 19, 2022, 10:20:36 pmQuote from: ravenrover on November 19, 2022, 05:22:26 pmNo comment on the verdict on the shooting down of the plane?Is that one shot down recently or the Malaysian one I commented on twice above? If you read “I am Bellingcat” by Elliot Ward Higgins you will see that from open sources the Buck missile launcher’s movements there in detail.It was tracked from an army base inside Russia to the launch site and then tracked back with one missile missing. There were even selfies and texts from the Russian crew.
That'll be the one you haven't commented about since the verdict was announced
Quote from: ravenrover on November 16, 2022, 06:03:26 pmQuote from: Bristol Red Rover on November 16, 2022, 04:20:01 pm32k civilians killed since Feb according to wiki, 25k of those in Mariupol. I know the western narrative on that is Russians waded in, but from a lot of what I saw and heard, the Azovs there were at least as responsible, and probably more callous in what they did. I guess that's a shock for you?Add to this that 3.5 to 5k civilians died between 2014 and end of 2021, including those on the Malaysian flight.And about 200 before the Donbas war started.To suggest these were all killed by Russia is plainly wrong. As for who did what, that will never be fully known. It is known that at least in the early months of the 2022 war, and especially in Mariupol, Ukraine troops near the frontlines based themselves in civilains areas and used human shields extensively.Malaysian flight, wonder who shot that down?Quite probably was a Donestk PR crew seriously screwing up, though we have no details. What the flight was doing anywhere near a war zone is also a question.
Quote from: Bristol Red Rover on November 16, 2022, 04:20:01 pm32k civilians killed since Feb according to wiki, 25k of those in Mariupol. I know the western narrative on that is Russians waded in, but from a lot of what I saw and heard, the Azovs there were at least as responsible, and probably more callous in what they did. I guess that's a shock for you?Add to this that 3.5 to 5k civilians died between 2014 and end of 2021, including those on the Malaysian flight.And about 200 before the Donbas war started.To suggest these were all killed by Russia is plainly wrong. As for who did what, that will never be fully known. It is known that at least in the early months of the 2022 war, and especially in Mariupol, Ukraine troops near the frontlines based themselves in civilains areas and used human shields extensively.Malaysian flight, wonder who shot that down?
32k civilians killed since Feb according to wiki, 25k of those in Mariupol. I know the western narrative on that is Russians waded in, but from a lot of what I saw and heard, the Azovs there were at least as responsible, and probably more callous in what they did. I guess that's a shock for you?Add to this that 3.5 to 5k civilians died between 2014 and end of 2021, including those on the Malaysian flight.And about 200 before the Donbas war started.To suggest these were all killed by Russia is plainly wrong. As for who did what, that will never be fully known. It is known that at least in the early months of the 2022 war, and especially in Mariupol, Ukraine troops near the frontlines based themselves in civilains areas and used human shields extensively.
Quote from: idler on November 20, 2022, 10:05:34 amQuote from: Bristol Red Rover on November 19, 2022, 10:20:36 pmQuote from: ravenrover on November 19, 2022, 05:22:26 pmNo comment on the verdict on the shooting down of the plane?Is that one shot down recently or the Malaysian one I commented on twice above? If you read “I am Bellingcat” by Elliot Ward Higgins you will see that from open sources the Buck missile launcher’s movements there in detail.It was tracked from an army base inside Russia to the launch site and then tracked back with one missile missing. There were even selfies and texts from the Russian crew.Bellingcat... yeah, right.Let's stick with the actual findings. And then tell me Ukraine hasn't committed any atrocities, including trying to start WW3.
Zakhar Prilepin - far right politician, major Putin apologist and founder of a mercenary battalion in Donetesk, admitting on national tv that any peace negotiations will only be a ruse and used by Russia to re-group and launch another attack.https://twitter.com/JuliaDavisNews/status/1594408064337301504But the US...
Quote from: Bristol Red Rover on November 16, 2022, 11:02:39 pmQuote from: ravenrover on November 16, 2022, 06:03:26 pmQuote from: Bristol Red Rover on November 16, 2022, 04:20:01 pm32k civilians killed since Feb according to wiki, 25k of those in Mariupol. I know the western narrative on that is Russians waded in, but from a lot of what I saw and heard, the Azovs there were at least as responsible, and probably more callous in what they did. I guess that's a shock for you?Add to this that 3.5 to 5k civilians died between 2014 and end of 2021, including those on the Malaysian flight.And about 200 before the Donbas war started.To suggest these were all killed by Russia is plainly wrong. As for who did what, that will never be fully known. It is known that at least in the early months of the 2022 war, and especially in Mariupol, Ukraine troops near the frontlines based themselves in civilains areas and used human shields extensively.Malaysian flight, wonder who shot that down?Quite probably was a Donestk PR crew seriously screwing up, though we have no details. What the flight was doing anywhere near a war zone is also a question.Well I've found this prior to the verdict but nothing since. Still blaming the pilot for flying too low or being in the wrong place. Of course even though 2 Russians have been found guilty no condemnation from you
But...but..."We don't know the details".
Quote from: Bristol Red Rover on November 20, 2022, 08:41:47 pmQuote from: idler on November 20, 2022, 10:05:34 amQuote from: Bristol Red Rover on November 19, 2022, 10:20:36 pmQuote from: ravenrover on November 19, 2022, 05:22:26 pmNo comment on the verdict on the shooting down of the plane?Is that one shot down recently or the Malaysian one I commented on twice above? If you read “I am Bellingcat” by Elliot Ward Higgins you will see that from open sources the Buck missile launcher’s movements there in detail.It was tracked from an army base inside Russia to the launch site and then tracked back with one missile missing. There were even selfies and texts from the Russian crew.Bellingcat... yeah, right.Let's stick with the actual findings. And then tell me Ukraine hasn't committed any atrocities, including trying to start WW3. Their findings were more credible than the official Russian findings and they cited where they got their information from.
Quote from: wilts rover on November 20, 2022, 08:44:05 pmZakhar Prilepin - far right politician, major Putin apologist and founder of a mercenary battalion in Donetesk, admitting on national tv that any peace negotiations will only be a ruse and used by Russia to re-group and launch another attack.https://twitter.com/JuliaDavisNews/status/1594408064337301504But the US...First, this guy has his agenda, war to make money. Second, he didn't actually say what you said.
Quote from: BillyStubbsTears on November 21, 2022, 09:37:10 amBut...but..."We don't know the details".Billy the wild west judge who doesn't need to know the details before pulling the trapdoor for the noose to do it's work. And if later is found to be wrong puts it down to bad luck. Nutter.
But...but..."We don't know the details".
Quote from: ravenrover on November 21, 2022, 09:31:34 amQuote from: Bristol Red Rover on November 16, 2022, 11:02:39 pmQuote from: ravenrover on November 16, 2022, 06:03:26 pmQuote from: Bristol Red Rover on November 16, 2022, 04:20:01 pm32k civilians killed since Feb according to wiki, 25k of those in Mariupol. I know the western narrative on that is Russians waded in, but from a lot of what I saw and heard, the Azovs there were at least as responsible, and probably more callous in what they did. I guess that's a shock for you?Add to this that 3.5 to 5k civilians died between 2014 and end of 2021, including those on the Malaysian flight.And about 200 before the Donbas war started.To suggest these were all killed by Russia is plainly wrong. As for who did what, that will never be fully known. It is known that at least in the early months of the 2022 war, and especially in Mariupol, Ukraine troops near the frontlines based themselves in civilains areas and used human shields extensively.Malaysian flight, wonder who shot that down?Quite probably was a Donestk PR crew seriously screwing up, though we have no details. What the flight was doing anywhere near a war zone is also a question.Well I've found this prior to the verdict but nothing since. Still blaming the pilot for flying too low or being in the wrong place. Of course even though 2 Russians have been found guilty no condemnation from youAnd afterwards I said it was just as I said. Condemnation... it's a conflict that has been fanned into a war which is condemnation enough for me. As for the specifics, I missed where there is an analysis of the exact process of decision making in choosing to fire the missile. Do I think they aimed to shoot down an airliner? Not at all, makes no sense whatsoever except in the mind of a psycho, but then the military and war moreso is a herding ground for psychos.The height of the flight, the pilot's decsion making I am not questioning although I think it was said they made a turn slightly, which may have put them in danger?? I question the wisdom of unnecessarily flying over a war zone - mental. I doubt you'd be happy in a plane doing that.
Quote from: Bristol Red Rover on November 21, 2022, 01:59:07 pmQuote from: wilts rover on November 20, 2022, 08:44:05 pmZakhar Prilepin - far right politician, major Putin apologist and founder of a mercenary battalion in Donetesk, admitting on national tv that any peace negotiations will only be a ruse and used by Russia to re-group and launch another attack.https://twitter.com/JuliaDavisNews/status/1594408064337301504But the US...First, this guy has his agenda, war to make money. Second, he didn't actually say what you said. He has an agenda but you dont? Funny old world...
Quote from: Bristol Red Rover on November 21, 2022, 02:33:03 pmQuote from: BillyStubbsTears on November 21, 2022, 09:37:10 amBut...but..."We don't know the details".Billy the wild west judge who doesn't need to know the details before pulling the trapdoor for the noose to do it's work. And if later is found to be wrong puts it down to bad luck. Nutter.There have been two investigations and a legal trial, all of which found clear evidence that the missile was Russian, provided and fired by Russian forces.But your precise words were that we didn't have details.You do this every single time. You blow smoke across any and every issue where Russia is clearly at fault. You are really not worth giving the time of day Quote from: ravenrover on November 22, 2022, 11:04:23 amQuote from: Bristol Red Rover on November 21, 2022, 02:30:09 pmQuote from: ravenrover on November 21, 2022, 09:31:34 amQuote from: Bristol Red Rover on November 16, 2022, 11:02:39 pmQuote from: ravenrover on November 16, 2022, 06:03:26 pmQuote from: Bristol Red Rover on November 16, 2022, 04:20:01 pm32k civilians killed since Feb according to wiki, 25k of those in Mariupol. I know the western narrative on that is Russians waded in, but from a lot of what I saw and heard, the Azovs there were at least as responsible, and probably more callous in what they did. I guess that's a shock for you?Add to this that 3.5 to 5k civilians died between 2014 and end of 2021, including those on the Malaysian flight.And about 200 before the Donbas war started.To suggest these were all killed by Russia is plainly wrong. As for who did what, that will never be fully known. It is known that at least in the early months of the 2022 war, and especially in Mariupol, Ukraine troops near the frontlines based themselves in civilains areas and used human shields extensively.Malaysian flight, wonder who shot that down?Quite probably was a Donestk PR crew seriously screwing up, though we have no details. What the flight was doing anywhere near a war zone is also a question.Well I've found this prior to the verdict but nothing since. Still blaming the pilot for flying too low or being in the wrong place. Of course even though 2 Russians have been found guilty no condemnation from youAnd afterwards I said it was just as I said. Condemnation... it's a conflict that has been fanned into a war which is condemnation enough for me. As for the specifics, I missed where there is an analysis of the exact process of decision making in choosing to fire the missile. Do I think they aimed to shoot down an airliner? Not at all, makes no sense whatsoever except in the mind of a psycho, but then the military and war moreso is a herding ground for psychos.The height of the flight, the pilot's decsion making I am not questioning although I think it was said they made a turn slightly, which may have put them in danger?? I question the wisdom of unnecessarily flying over a war zone - mental. I doubt you'd be happy in a plane doing that.Excellent whataboutery there BRR no more than expectedSeems you don't understand whataboutery except as a Internet forum rhetoric to try to out someone down and avoid dealing with an issue. No need for it.
Quote from: BillyStubbsTears on November 21, 2022, 09:37:10 amBut...but..."We don't know the details".Billy the wild west judge who doesn't need to know the details before pulling the trapdoor for the noose to do it's work. And if later is found to be wrong puts it down to bad luck. Nutter.
But...but..."We don't know the details".
Quote from: Bristol Red Rover on November 21, 2022, 02:30:09 pmQuote from: ravenrover on November 21, 2022, 09:31:34 amQuote from: Bristol Red Rover on November 16, 2022, 11:02:39 pmQuote from: ravenrover on November 16, 2022, 06:03:26 pmQuote from: Bristol Red Rover on November 16, 2022, 04:20:01 pm32k civilians killed since Feb according to wiki, 25k of those in Mariupol. I know the western narrative on that is Russians waded in, but from a lot of what I saw and heard, the Azovs there were at least as responsible, and probably more callous in what they did. I guess that's a shock for you?Add to this that 3.5 to 5k civilians died between 2014 and end of 2021, including those on the Malaysian flight.And about 200 before the Donbas war started.To suggest these were all killed by Russia is plainly wrong. As for who did what, that will never be fully known. It is known that at least in the early months of the 2022 war, and especially in Mariupol, Ukraine troops near the frontlines based themselves in civilains areas and used human shields extensively.Malaysian flight, wonder who shot that down?Quite probably was a Donestk PR crew seriously screwing up, though we have no details. What the flight was doing anywhere near a war zone is also a question.Well I've found this prior to the verdict but nothing since. Still blaming the pilot for flying too low or being in the wrong place. Of course even though 2 Russians have been found guilty no condemnation from youAnd afterwards I said it was just as I said. Condemnation... it's a conflict that has been fanned into a war which is condemnation enough for me. As for the specifics, I missed where there is an analysis of the exact process of decision making in choosing to fire the missile. Do I think they aimed to shoot down an airliner? Not at all, makes no sense whatsoever except in the mind of a psycho, but then the military and war moreso is a herding ground for psychos.The height of the flight, the pilot's decsion making I am not questioning although I think it was said they made a turn slightly, which may have put them in danger?? I question the wisdom of unnecessarily flying over a war zone - mental. I doubt you'd be happy in a plane doing that.Excellent whataboutery there BRR no more than expected
Quote from: Bristol Red Rover on November 21, 2022, 02:33:03 pmQuote from: BillyStubbsTears on November 21, 2022, 09:37:10 amBut...but..."We don't know the details".Billy the wild west judge who doesn't need to know the details before pulling the trapdoor for the noose to do it's work. And if later is found to be wrong puts it down to bad luck. Nutter.There have been two investigations and a legal trial, all of which found clear evidence that the missile was Russian, provided and fired by Russian forces.But your precise words were that we didn't have details.You do this every single time. You blow smoke across any and every issue where Russia is clearly at fault. You are really not worth giving the time of day to.
Bern saying this for years https://mobile.twitter.com/PhillipsPOBrien/status/1595390115211247617The far left and far right have a hell of a lot in common.Many of the key British far right today (Claire Fox, Mick Hume as examples) were Revolutionary Communists 25 years ago.And I'm sure that Corbynistas would not agree that Russia is a terrorist state, despite us seeing Russian terrorism on our screens every single day.