Which players from SOD's era would get into our current team?

[Wade Falana]

Which players (in their prime) from the squads of 2006-2009 would make the current team?

Plenty to choose from, JJ, Heffs, Sully etc etc.

I'll start with Billy Sharp and Matt Mills. Greeny on the bench.

[Axo]

JoC, Mills, Shackell, stock, Sharp, Greeny

[Belle_Vue]

Joc before he got moved all over defence.

Sully on he bench allowing maxted to be loaned out

Shackell better then mills imo

[sedwardsdrfc]

For me quite a few. JOC, Gareth Roberts, Mills, Shackell, Stock, Green, Sharp and even Hird he was quite good for a time

[Donnyrovers]

For me quite a few. JOC, Gareth Roberts, Mills, Shackell, Stock, Green, Sharp and even Hird he was quite good for a time

Hird???? Not a f***ing chance he was shite.

[DRNaith]

Wellens

[bigal]

Jason Price

[ctay]

Sharp, Stock, Shackell, JOC, Mills, Gareth Roberts and Green.

[Wild Rover]

None apart from the one we have.

[RoversAlias]

For me, if you're going with them at their peak for the club, I'd have all of these:

Jimmy OC
Mills
Friend
Stock
Oster (09/10 vintage only)
Hayter
Sharp

Top class loanees also:

Jordon Mutch
JET
Jason Shackell
Elliott Ward

[IDM]

Elliott Ward only for THAT goal at Hillsboro' ?

[The Beast]

For me quite a few. JOC, Gareth Roberts, Mills, Shackell, Stock, Green, Sharp and even Hird he was quite good for a time

Hird???? Not a f***ing chance he was shite.

Not very eloquently put but have to agree.

[jonnydog]

For me quite a few. JOC, Gareth Roberts, Mills, Shackell, Stock, Green, Sharp and even Hird he was quite good for a time

Hird???? Not a f***ing chance he was shite.

You ARE Benaldo and I claim my £5

[Wade Falana]

Mixture of both squads, reckon this would do alright.

Turnbull

JOC
Husband
Shackell
Mills

Copps
Wellens
Stock
JET

Sharp
Heffs

Subs. Sully, Green, Chris Brown, Duffy, Rob Jones, Oster, JJ

[DonnyBazR0ver]

Have to agree with the majority on here.

For me, there would be 3 players that would have an immediate impact on our fortunes if (at their prime) they were slotted in to the current team.

Gareth Roberts and JO'C. Proper full backs defending and attacking, reading the game and adapting to counter the opposition.

Billy Sharp. Blatantly obvious why.

[aidanstu]

Can't believe so many would have green in the side. He had a decent six months before he went but a quiet three years before that. Sharp, mills, stock, o'connor, Roberts, shackell and mills would all get in the side for me.

[The Red Baron]

Mixture of both squads, reckon this would do alright.

Turnbull

JOC
Husband
Shackell
Mills

Copps
Wellens
Stock
JET

Sharp
Heffs

Subs. Sully, Green, Chris Brown, Duffy, Rob Jones, Oster, JJ

I like that team. My only change would be Gareth Roberts in place of Husband.

[Superspy]

Can't believe so many would have green in the side. He had a decent six months before he went but a quiet three years before that. Sharp, mills, stock, o'connor, Roberts, shackell and mills would all get in the side for me.

Mills so good you named him twice? I assume you aren't on about his brother...