0 Members and 3 Guests are viewing this topic.
TRBThe EU cannot require us to do any such thing. What they can and absolutely SHOULD do is require our Govt to have a clear strategy for what it is going to do with the delay, so that we don't end up in the same shit show in 1, 3, 6, 12 or 24 months time.If the Govt decides that it can't do that without a Ref2 or a GE, that is entirely the Govt's choice.Equally, the Govt could choose to rescind A50. What it can't do is to decide to crash out with No Deal, because Parliament has instructed it not to do so in any circumstances. Be clear about this, because the nutter Right will start the lies very soon. Whatever we do after May goes to Brussels will be OUR decision. WE have brought this f**king mess on ourselves. None of it is the fault of the EU.
Quote from: Muttley on March 18, 2019, 10:06:14 pmQuote from: The Red Baron on March 18, 2019, 09:47:34 pmOr May could grab the spirit of the proposed Kyle / Wilson amendment (which won't happen now that MV3 won't happen) and propose a Referendum of her dead vs. Remain. Now there's something I could vote for!That WOULD be a divisive referendum...
Quote from: The Red Baron on March 18, 2019, 09:47:34 pmOr May could grab the spirit of the proposed Kyle / Wilson amendment (which won't happen now that MV3 won't happen) and propose a Referendum of her dead vs. Remain. Now there's something I could vote for!
Or May could grab the spirit of the proposed Kyle / Wilson amendment (which won't happen now that MV3 won't happen) and propose a Referendum of her dead vs. Remain.
Quote from: RedJ on March 19, 2019, 08:28:54 amQuote from: Muttley on March 18, 2019, 10:06:14 pmQuote from: The Red Baron on March 18, 2019, 09:47:34 pmOr May could grab the spirit of the proposed Kyle / Wilson amendment (which won't happen now that MV3 won't happen) and propose a Referendum of her dead vs. Remain. Now there's something I could vote for!That WOULD be a divisive referendum... To be fair we could try each for 5 years to see which works best !
Wing Co.As I was saying...https://mobile.twitter.com/GwynneMP/status/1107741970141798401Complicated, int it?
Genuine question, by revoking article 50 now what is there to stop it being resurrected further down the line? Or is it a case of you only get 1 go?
So your saying the government should ignore the will of the people and rekoke article 50?That would remove all semblance of democracy, government and rule of law.We really would be in the realms of the unknown. It certainly isn't a solution. After all this You've STILL got your remain tinted specs on. It's time to remove them, and think rationally.
that vote wasn't legally binding
Quote from: Boomstick on March 19, 2019, 09:28:33 amSo your saying the government should ignore the will of the people and rekoke article 50?That would remove all semblance of democracy, government and rule of law.We really would be in the realms of the unknown. It certainly isn't a solution. After all this You've STILL got your remain tinted specs on. It's time to remove them, and think rationally. To quote your own words back at you:Quotethat vote wasn't legally bindingI'm glad you finally appreciated what that phrase means.
Quote from: Glyn_Wigley on March 19, 2019, 03:26:15 pmQuote from: Boomstick on March 19, 2019, 09:28:33 amSo your saying the government should ignore the will of the people and rekoke article 50?That would remove all semblance of democracy, government and rule of law.We really would be in the realms of the unknown. It certainly isn't a solution. After all this You've STILL got your remain tinted specs on. It's time to remove them, and think rationally. To quote your own words back at you:Quotethat vote wasn't legally bindingI'm glad you finally appreciated what that phrase means.Maybe, let's see what happens if they revoke it then.
Quote from: the vicar on December 03, 2018, 08:42:41 pmIt isn't its the minority shouting there mouths of but a vote is a vote is a vote END OF weather you like it or notTrue and you may have seen me post this before on hereA vote is a vote is a vote - so what happened in 1976 ? 66% voted Remain 34 % voted Leave. Thats a 10 times bigger majority than 2016The Tory euro sceptics never respected it and their spawn are still at it 40 years laterSo is that a vote you accept whether you voted for Leave or Remain ?
It isn't its the minority shouting there mouths of but a vote is a vote is a vote END OF weather you like it or not
Quote from: ravenrover on March 19, 2019, 12:57:49 pmGenuine question, by revoking article 50 now what is there to stop it being resurrected further down the line? Or is it a case of you only get 1 go?No reason why it couldn't be invoked again.