Viking Supporters Co-operative
Viking Chat => Viking Chat => Topic started by: donnyguy61 on January 20, 2018, 08:33:31 pm
-
http://www.skysports.com/watch/video/sports/football/competitions/league-one/11216344/did-this-cross-the-line (http://www.skysports.com/watch/video/sports/football/competitions/league-one/11216344/did-this-cross-the-line)
-
Yes.........the linesman indicated that it did! :)
-
Impossible to tell from that camera angle..
-
Use the "remove" button and it will go !
However I think it was a goal. We have had such a raw deal lately that it must have been in. Lino was off like f**k so he was convinced !
GOAL !
Seriously Technology needed in all 4 Divisions !
PS Crap goalkeeping !
-
Not the best of angles to judge. But, hey, it counted. So good enough for me.
-
The keepers right foot is almost touching the metal pole that holds the net down so he would have had to have long arms to keep the ball in play without falling over.
Anyway, it appears to be that the officials are always right so it must have been a goal.
Marquis seems to be convinced it is a goal straight away.
The fans reaction behind the goal is very positive about it too.
-
Yes.........the linesman indicated that it did! :)
Don’t we just love Lino’s ......... this weekend
COYR
-
It may have defied the laws of Physics, but not the laws of Khemistry :chair:
-
Dutch, just back it was definitely over in my opinion, even sat behind the goal it looked over he spilled it badly and fell back from what I could see, he looked very guilty and doing the "not on my watch" movements, as I say, over for me...
-
I too thought it was over, just couldn’t resist the pun ;)
-
Shrewsbury fans haven't argued the decision and think it was over line as well on their forum.
-
Shrewsbury fans haven't argued the decision and think it was over line as well on their forum.
And so did their players after the game. They gave a few interviews and never argued anything different.
-
Dutch, just back it was definitely over in my opinion, even sat behind the goal it looked over he spilled it badly and fell back from what I could see, he looked very guilty and doing the "not on my watch" movements, as I say, over for me...
Absolutely, it was over the line. It was a very funny moment when the keeper realised that he hadn't been so smart after all, holding the ball out at arm's length thinking he'd prevented it from going in only to then find himself standing in the back of the goal! And a great reaction from the Rovers fans behind him! As a fan you live for moments like that. Particularly as we've suffered from so many of them over the years!
-
I thought it was over the line, although I was quite a distance from the incident.
Bentley, in fact.
-
Now that defies the laws of Physics, Chemistry and Biology all at the same time :lol:
-
The linesman was in perfect position to see it as was stood next to the corner flag.
From behind the goal the keepers feet were well behind the line, as to the keepers hands with the ball firmly in his grasp impossible to say. The Lino did not hesitate and gave the goal immediately.
To be honest this Lino was excellent all afternoon and did not hesitate in any of his decisions. Probably the best Lino I have seen all season.
-
I don't give s**t, we've had some bad luck so far this season and it's about time Lady Luck was in our side for a change
-
Shrewsbury fans haven't argued the decision and think it was over line as well on their forum.
And so did their players after the game. They gave a few interviews and never argued anything different.
The keeper was straight over to the assistant at full time having words with him, I'd guess about the goal.
-
I don't give s**t, we've had some bad luck so far this season and it's about time Lady Luck was in our side for a change
As I have previously said, luck does tend to even out over a season.
-
As my mate said at the time, Henderson didn't relish that.
-
Got himself into a pickle.
-
I listened to Radio Shropshire after the match and the regular commentators said that Henderson was very well known for getting far close in previous matches to crossing the line when catching the ball and it had been coming.
I was four rows back and CERTAINLY in.
-
He nearly did it a few minutes earlier. He did exactly the same by catching the ball and taking a step back but just stayed the right side of the line the first time.
-
Impossible to tell from that angle. A pretty pointless video by sky in truth. They could have just stuck to the normal highlights.
Although everybody I have spoken to or seen comment that attended have said it looked well over. Everybody apart from Henderson himself who has tweeted to say "never a goal." Although he is going to say that isn't he. Huge gaff from him really.
-
Their manager said it wasn't over AND that the goalie was fouled.
He went that far back he was in a different post code.
-
Yeah, but don’t forget that Adams said the Coppinger incident wasn’t a pen either last week.
Only to be expected by the keeper and Hurst.
-
Their manager said it wasn't over AND that the goalie was fouled.
He went that far back he was in a different post code.
How the f**k could the manager possibly have been able to tell? f**king cock.
-
Their manager said it wasn't over AND that the goalie was fouled.
He went that far back he was in a different post code.
How the f**k could the manager possibly have been able to tell? f**king cock.
He will be repeating what the keeper told him probably.
-
Linesman last week would Definately not given it.
-
Does anyone think we should not have been given it ? We’ve earned this after all the stupid decisions that’s gone against us over this season. VAR they can stick that pile of scrap metal in the bin , I’d sooner have a blind officials than geeks running the game.
-
Not conclusive , but judging by the keepers feet and Baudry's position i'd say yes.
(http://i372.photobucket.com/albums/oo164/eastender1/baud_zpswgxiztbj.png) (http://s372.photobucket.com/user/eastender1/media/baud_zpswgxiztbj.png.html)
-
I don't give s**t, we've had some bad luck so far this season and it's about time Lady Luck was in our side for a change
Yep we were owed that if it wasn't and if it was then we still have one in the tank for when we next need it .
-
Now that defies the laws of Physics, Chemistry and Biology all at the same time :lol:
... not Alkhemy though !
-
Paul Hurst, Shrews' manager, said that he hasn't seen any evidence that the ball crossed the line. Err, excuse me, the evidence was the linesman indicating with his flag that the ball had, indeed, crossed the line. Gawd only knows what his reaction would have been if the incident had been at the other end. Would he then have said that no evidence was available. 'Course he wouldn't! :facepalm:
Sheer hypocrisy!
-
Look like clear evidence in my Paper - where it says 2-2 !
You are right though in that had they scored in similar fashion he would have said "it was a clear goal - and my Players reactions confirmed that to me - they were the only evidence I needed"
-
Doesn’t this add to DF’s defence , of his belief that officials are not up to the standard required .
-
Its a hard one to judge I suppose and its the one decision that should be definitive
Goal Line Technology HAS to come to every Division. Its too big a business to "perhaps" get the mostimportant decision wrong
Rochdale away anyone ? Yeovil at home ? Geoff Hurst 66 Lampard a couple of Seasons back ?
-
very brave of the linesman ,he could have ignored it like most of them would have ,did we give him a lift home ?
-
Its a hard one to judge I suppose and its the one decision that should be definitive
Goal Line Technology HAS to come to every Division. Its too big a business to "perhaps" get the mostimportant decision wrong
Rochdale away anyone ? Yeovil at home ? Geoff Hurst 66 Lampard a couple of Seasons back ?
Wolfi3, we both know how quickly time passes.
Lampard a couple of seasons back. That was actually in 2010.
-
no it wasn't and don't care. we deserve a bit of luck for a change.
-
The linesman gave it immediately. No hesitation at all so that says enough for me. Any doubt he wouldn’t have given it would he???
This Lino was very good and did not wait for the ref on any decisions.
Goal Goal Goal Score 2-2 It’s in the record books and will not change.
-
I've just scientifically solved the issue using geometrical evidence.......
Case solved!
-
Doesn’t this add to DF’s defence , of his belief that officials are not up to the standard required .
Nope, precisely the opposite. Unlike the dope who ran the line last week the linesman yesterday was spot on. He had a good game and was an example of how high the quality of officiating is/can be in this League. The point is that there's a degree of inconsistency among the refereeing fraternity that needs to be ironed out Professionalisation will help, however, it still won't legislate for human error and officials losing concentration at key moments; that will always be part of the game.
-
I've just scientifically solved the issue using geometrical evidence.......
Case solved!
Nice one. CASE CLOSED.
-
I have seen this from a video behind the net. He catches it under the bar and falls backwards. It's well over the line
-
I too have now seen the highlights and imho there is NO DOUBT that the whole of the Ball crossed the line
-
A nice young lady on the coach back ( Donny Dogs Minder ) had several very good pictures on her Apple tablet showing the goalie catching the ball then stepping backwards and the ball CLEARLY well over the line. It also showed he was not fouled by any Rovers player. result. On another matter their first goal came from a corner that should have been a goal kick as it was their player it came off.
-
The linesman was in perfect position to see it as was stood next to the corner flag.
From behind the goal the keepers feet were well behind the line, as to the keepers hands with the ball firmly in his grasp impossible to say. The Lino did not hesitate and gave the goal immediately.
To be honest this Lino was excellent all afternoon and did not hesitate in any of his decisions. Probably the best Lino I have seen all season.
Except that he didn't give the blatant foul on Marquis when he was clean through and hauled down about 20 yards out. Not saying we'd have scored but it would have reduced them to 10
-
The linesman was in perfect position to see it as was stood next to the corner flag.
From behind the goal the keepers feet were well behind the line, as to the keepers hands with the ball firmly in his grasp impossible to say. The Lino did not hesitate and gave the goal immediately.
To be honest this Lino was excellent all afternoon and did not hesitate in any of his decisions. Probably the best Lino I have seen all season.
Except that he didn't give the blatant foul on Marquis when he was clean through and hauled down about 20 yards out. Not saying we'd have scored but it would have reduced them to 10
Can’t remember that one!
-
It was fairly late on. I was screaming for a foul to be given. Just took him down as he was virtually on the edge of the box. Not even a free kick given.
-
behind the goal angle: https://twitter.com/FleegleJason/status/954844425951301632
not conclusive though
-
behind the goal angle: https://twitter.com/FleegleJason/status/954844425951301632
not conclusive though
I'd give it :rtid:
-
From the Shrews fans Board.
http://blueandamber.proboards.com/thread/96227/ (http://blueandamber.proboards.com/thread/96227/)
-
From the Shrews fans Board.
http://blueandamber.proboards.com/thread/96227/ (http://blueandamber.proboards.com/thread/96227/)
They're a good deal more fair-minded than a lot of fans you come across on forums. Imagine if that was Plymouth?
-
I hate Plymouth. Horrible little club with a horrible fan base.
-
I hate Plymouth. Horrible little club with a horrible fan base.
You certainly know how to wind them up. One of the things that always gets me about them is how they think they are a much bigger club than they are.