Viking Supporters Co-operative

Viking Chat => Off Topic => Topic started by: Axholme Lion on December 17, 2019, 02:04:47 pm

Title: Wouldn't it be nice...
Post by: Axholme Lion on December 17, 2019, 02:04:47 pm
...if after the last three years that people could finally put the opinions on both sides of Brexit and the election to bed and finally start to come together for the good of the country. In all votes there will be a winner and a loser. It would be good for the winners not to gloat and to use their position of power to do the best for one and all in our nation, I would hope to see more investment in the future of the north. Also it would be nice for the losers to graciously accept defeat and not to keep raking over the coals of the past so we can all move on together.
Title: Re: Wouldn't it be nice...
Post by: Not Now Kato on December 17, 2019, 03:03:26 pm
Nice thoughts AL, but the moment Johnson put No Deal back on the table all bets are off.
Title: Re: Wouldn't it be nice...
Post by: Axholme Lion on December 17, 2019, 03:46:22 pm
Nice thoughts AL, but the moment Johnson put No Deal back on the table all bets are off.

I think he has to put it back on the table in order to negotiate from a position of strength in order to get the best deal possible from the Europeans. This is where the UK went wrong in the past by saying we would not just walk away. It's bound to focus their minds more to make them more reasonable to our requirements.
Title: Re: Wouldn't it be nice...
Post by: albie on December 17, 2019, 03:57:23 pm
The issue is that the EU want no backsliding on current standards  in order to agree a deal on terms similar to those at the moment.

The US require exactly the opposite....free market access to UK goods and services, with regulatory reform.

Very difficult to see how you can have both, so one will be downgraded against the other.

Johnson will blame the EU and default to "no deal" in December 2020, leaving on WTO rules in future.
This will massively impact UK manufacturing, much of which will relocate to the EU proper.

At the same time, an economic downturn is brewing and will cascade through the UK economy.
Johnson has zero understanding of the economic system, and does not care other than for the political outfall.

All looking good, eh!
Title: Re: Wouldn't it be nice...
Post by: selby on December 17, 2019, 04:01:20 pm
  It will not die down for a while yet. The losers have took  three and a half years to come to terms with their first loss up to press, they have got to find something else to crow about yet.
  Not an easy thing to do when you haven't a lot else to do with your time.
Title: Re: Wouldn't it be nice...
Post by: Not Now Kato on December 17, 2019, 04:05:47 pm
Nice thoughts AL, but the moment Johnson put No Deal back on the table all bets are off.

I think he has to put it back on the table in order to negotiate from a position of strength in order to get the best deal possible from the Europeans. This is where the UK went wrong in the past by saying we would not just walk away. It's bound to focus their minds more to make them more reasonable to our requirements.

IF it works, and it's a big IF.  But if it fails he has left himself nowhere to go - and that would be disastrous for the country.  One of the principal rules in negotiations is 'never threaten to do something you know will hurt you if it has to be done, without a way out'.  And I've conducted a very large number of successful negotiations over the years.
Title: Re: Wouldn't it be nice...
Post by: Not Now Kato on December 17, 2019, 04:07:25 pm
  It will not die down for a while yet. The losers have took  three and a half years to come to terms with their first loss up to press, they have got to find something else to crow about yet.
  Not an easy thing to do when you haven't a lot else to do with your time.

None of that makes any sense!
Title: Re: Wouldn't it be nice...
Post by: Axholme Lion on December 17, 2019, 04:25:36 pm
Nice thoughts AL, but the moment Johnson put No Deal back on the table all bets are off.

I think he has to put it back on the table in order to negotiate from a position of strength in order to get the best deal possible from the Europeans. This is where the UK went wrong in the past by saying we would not just walk away. It's bound to focus their minds more to make them more reasonable to our requirements.

IF it works, and it's a big IF.  But if it fails he has left himself nowhere to go - and that would be disastrous for the country.  One of the principal rules in negotiations is 'never threaten to do something you know will hurt you if it has to be done, without a way out'.  And I've conducted a very large number of successful negotiations over the years.

Well I hope everyone can get behind the negotiations of the Government. Regardless of personal political preferences what is done is done and we should all hope for the best outcome for Britain. Had Labour won the election I would have hoped that they would have done the best for us all and would have wished them well in their efforts.
Title: Re: Wouldn't it be nice...
Post by: drfchound on December 17, 2019, 04:33:04 pm
At the end of the day, had the referendum outcome been to remain then we wouldn’t have had to be discussing this subject.
On the home political scene I don’t think there is a snowball in hells chance of the other Parties supporting the government through the Brexit negotiations.
Point scoring opportunities are to be had.
Title: Re: Wouldn't it be nice...
Post by: Axholme Lion on December 17, 2019, 04:52:34 pm
At the end of the day, had the referendum outcome been to remain then we wouldn’t have had to be discussing this subject.
On the home political scene I don’t think there is a snowball in hells chance of the other Parties supporting the government through the Brexit negotiations.
Point scoring opportunities are to be had.

If the opposition parties had been more supportive in the past couple of years maybe they would have done better in the general election, rather than being perceived as obstructive.
Title: Re: Wouldn't it be nice...
Post by: glosterred on December 17, 2019, 05:01:07 pm
Taking no deal off the table in the first place was like playing cards and showing the other players what cards you’re holding. Not very cleverly and bound to make you lose money



Title: Re: Wouldn't it be nice...
Post by: Not Now Kato on December 17, 2019, 05:10:34 pm
Nice thoughts AL, but the moment Johnson put No Deal back on the table all bets are off.

I think he has to put it back on the table in order to negotiate from a position of strength in order to get the best deal possible from the Europeans. This is where the UK went wrong in the past by saying we would not just walk away. It's bound to focus their minds more to make them more reasonable to our requirements.

IF it works, and it's a big IF.  But if it fails he has left himself nowhere to go - and that would be disastrous for the country.  One of the principal rules in negotiations is 'never threaten to do something you know will hurt you if it has to be done, without a way out'.  And I've conducted a very large number of successful negotiations over the years.

Well I hope everyone can get behind the negotiations of the Government. Regardless of personal political preferences what is done is done and we should all hope for the best outcome for Britain. Had Labour won the election I would have hoped that they would have done the best for us all and would have wished them well in their efforts.

Agreed.  But it will need Johnson to take a more conciliatory stance at home in the UK; which, sadly, I don't think Cummings will allow him to do.
Title: Re: Wouldn't it be nice...
Post by: Glyn_Wigley on December 17, 2019, 05:56:55 pm
Nice thoughts AL, but the moment Johnson put No Deal back on the table all bets are off.

I think he has to put it back on the table in order to negotiate from a position of strength in order to get the best deal possible from the Europeans. This is where the UK went wrong in the past by saying we would not just walk away. It's bound to focus their minds more to make them more reasonable to our requirements.

What about the 'wonderful' deal he's already got that he was pissed off about Parliament wanting time to scrutise?

If I remember rightly, you were wanting everybody to get behind that one as well.
Title: Re: Wouldn't it be nice...
Post by: Axholme Lion on December 18, 2019, 09:16:44 am
Nice thoughts AL, but the moment Johnson put No Deal back on the table all bets are off.

I think he has to put it back on the table in order to negotiate from a position of strength in order to get the best deal possible from the Europeans. This is where the UK went wrong in the past by saying we would not just walk away. It's bound to focus their minds more to make them more reasonable to our requirements.

What about the 'wonderful' deal he's already got that he was pissed off about Parliament wanting time to scrutise?

If I remember rightly, you were wanting everybody to get behind that one as well.

I just want us to do the best we can for the benefit of all our nation. Happy Christmas.
Title: Re: Wouldn't it be nice...
Post by: Bentley Bullet on December 18, 2019, 09:54:00 am
Perhaps we could arrange a Remainers v Leavers Christmas day football match reminiscent of the WW1 England/Germany Christmas day truce in 1914.

Just to appease the Remainers, in the event of a Leave win we could re-play the game on Boxing day.
Title: Re: Wouldn't it be nice...
Post by: Axholme Lion on December 18, 2019, 09:58:26 am
Perhaps we could arrange a Remainers v Leavers Christmas day football match reminiscent of the WW1 England/Germany Christmas day truce in 1914.

Just to appease the Remainers, in the event of a Leave win we could re-play the game on Boxing day.

 :) :) :)
Title: Re: Wouldn't it be nice...
Post by: bobjimwilly on December 18, 2019, 12:45:10 pm
All us remoaners will just wait 20+ years like those who lost the first EU referendum in 1975 and never "got over it"

And threatening the EU with no deal is like promising someone you will shoot yourself in the head before shooting them
Title: Re: Wouldn't it be nice...
Post by: DonnyOsmond on December 18, 2019, 01:11:54 pm
Perhaps we could arrange a Remainers v Leavers Christmas day football match reminiscent of the WW1 England/Germany Christmas day truce in 1914.

Just to appease the Remainers, in the event of a Leave win we could re-play the game on Boxing day.

You Leavers might struggle with all your zimmer frames.
Title: Re: Wouldn't it be nice...
Post by: ravenrover on December 18, 2019, 01:49:06 pm
Perhaps we could arrange a Remainers v Leavers Christmas day football match reminiscent of the WW1 England/Germany Christmas day truce in 1914.

Just to appease the Remainers, in the event of a Leave win we could re-play the game on Boxing day.
Suppose it all depends on whether each team could get 11players per team before they change their minds as to which side they want to be on ...…………… oh sorry forgot it's only MPs who are allowed to change their mind not the great unwashed public
Title: Re: Wouldn't it be nice...
Post by: Glyn_Wigley on December 18, 2019, 01:59:47 pm
Nice thoughts AL, but the moment Johnson put No Deal back on the table all bets are off.

I think he has to put it back on the table in order to negotiate from a position of strength in order to get the best deal possible from the Europeans. This is where the UK went wrong in the past by saying we would not just walk away. It's bound to focus their minds more to make them more reasonable to our requirements.

What about the 'wonderful' deal he's already got that he was pissed off about Parliament wanting time to scrutise?

If I remember rightly, you were wanting everybody to get behind that one as well.

I just want us to do the best we can for the benefit of all our nation. Happy Christmas.

And that is exactly what those who wish the UK to remain in the EU want too. Happy Christmas.
Title: Re: Wouldn't it be nice...
Post by: scawsby steve on December 18, 2019, 02:56:28 pm
Perhaps we could arrange a Remainers v Leavers Christmas day football match reminiscent of the WW1 England/Germany Christmas day truce in 1914.

Just to appease the Remainers, in the event of a Leave win we could re-play the game on Boxing day.

You Leavers might struggle with all your zimmer frames.

Here we go again, same old insults.

See you in 2024 for another pasting. Don't be late.
Title: Re: Wouldn't it be nice...
Post by: BillyStubbsTears on December 18, 2019, 03:15:47 pm
All us remoaners will just wait 20+ years like those who lost the first EU referendum in 1975 and never "got over it"

And threatening the EU with no deal is like promising someone you will shoot yourself in the head before shooting them

INSTEAD of shooting them BJW. Instead.
Title: Re: Wouldn't it be nice...
Post by: wilts rover on December 18, 2019, 05:26:21 pm
Perhaps we could arrange a Remainers v Leavers Christmas day football match reminiscent of the WW1 England/Germany Christmas day truce in 1914.

Just to appease the Remainers, in the event of a Leave win we could re-play the game on Boxing day.

But if the soldiers had done what they signed up for there would not have been a truce.

The high command tried to ban it in 1914 and issued orders for court martial of any soldier declaring a truce in 1915.

Which is a great example of the type of movement that encompasses a 'people's vote'. Ordinary people disobeying the orders of their superiors who don't want them to think for themselves but do only what they tell them.

https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-england-kent-37256796
Title: Re: Wouldn't it be nice...
Post by: Bentley Bullet on December 18, 2019, 05:32:11 pm
.....But I don't recall a people's vote on going to war, so where's the similarity?
Title: Re: Wouldn't it be nice...
Post by: drfchound on December 18, 2019, 08:12:51 pm
Nice thoughts AL, but the moment Johnson put No Deal back on the table all bets are off.

I think he has to put it back on the table in order to negotiate from a position of strength in order to get the best deal possible from the Europeans. This is where the UK went wrong in the past by saying we would not just walk away. It's bound to focus their minds more to make them more reasonable to our requirements.

What about the 'wonderful' deal he's already got that he was pissed off about Parliament wanting time to scrutise?

If I remember rightly, you were wanting everybody to get behind that one as well.

I just want us to do the best we can for the benefit of all our nation. Happy Christmas.

And that is exactly what those who wish the UK to remain in the EU want too. Happy Christmas.







Glyn..........I don’t believe I ......am.....writing.....this.........but.......I agree with you.
There.....I have said it.
Title: Re: Wouldn't it be nice...
Post by: DonnyOsmond on December 21, 2019, 02:46:44 pm
Perhaps we could arrange a Remainers v Leavers Christmas day football match reminiscent of the WW1 England/Germany Christmas day truce in 1914.

Just to appease the Remainers, in the event of a Leave win we could re-play the game on Boxing day.

You Leavers might struggle with all your zimmer frames.

Here we go again, same old insults.

See you in 2024 for another pasting. Don't be late.

I was kidding Hun x
Title: Re: Wouldn't it be nice...
Post by: DonnyOsmond on December 21, 2019, 02:59:57 pm
Perhaps we could arrange a Remainers v Leavers Christmas day football match reminiscent of the WW1 England/Germany Christmas day truce in 1914.

Just to appease the Remainers, in the event of a Leave win we could re-play the game on Boxing day.

You Leavers might struggle with all your zimmer frames.

Here we go again, same old insults.

See you in 2024 for another pasting. Don't be late.

Actually the the last line does make the question. If Boris did Get Brexit Done and it was a complete disaster, would you still vote for him anyway or would you realise he's led you down the garden path and reject him?
Title: Re: Wouldn't it be nice...
Post by: selby on December 21, 2019, 07:03:29 pm
   There is a good chance that the EU will be a lot weaker by 2024, Holland has a good chance of becoming Europes Mexico, with a massive drug problem, Germany's automobile industry will come in for increasing pressure from China and the far east in particular, and the Mediterranean countries will still be behind the northern countries.
   Poland will become more troublesome as they move from money receivers to actually putting money into the coffers, and the eastern members continue to resist accepting economic refugees, and France's main markets in the Middle East either become more troublesome, or more self sufficient themselves.
Title: Re: Wouldn't it be nice...
Post by: BillyStubbsTears on December 21, 2019, 07:58:29 pm
And yet again Selby. Negatives.

What positive things do you actually want? All I've ever heard from you is negatives.
Title: Re: Wouldn't it be nice...
Post by: selby on December 21, 2019, 08:04:12 pm
  Anything you disagree with there then Billy.
Title: Re: Wouldn't it be nice...
Post by: scawsby steve on December 21, 2019, 08:13:51 pm
Perhaps we could arrange a Remainers v Leavers Christmas day football match reminiscent of the WW1 England/Germany Christmas day truce in 1914.

Just to appease the Remainers, in the event of a Leave win we could re-play the game on Boxing day.

You Leavers might struggle with all your zimmer frames.

Here we go again, same old insults.

See you in 2024 for another pasting. Don't be late.

Actually the the last line does make the question. If Boris did Get Brexit Done and it was a complete disaster, would you still vote for him anyway or would you realise he's led you down the garden path and reject him?

I didn't vote for him this time, let alone next time.

The Tories didn't win the Election, Labour lost it.
Title: Re: Wouldn't it be nice...
Post by: BillyStubbsTears on December 21, 2019, 08:15:02 pm
Whether I agree or disagree with any of that is irrelevant.

You've won on that issue. We ARE leaving the EU. That's a battle you no longer have to fight.

But I've still got no idea of what you actually DO want us to be. I know plenty of what you dislike, but I'm genuinely interested in what positive things you want for the future.
Title: Re: Wouldn't it be nice...
Post by: selby on December 21, 2019, 08:18:31 pm
 Something positive then, A conservative PM will be in power for the next ten years.
Title: Re: Wouldn't it be nice...
Post by: BillyStubbsTears on December 21, 2019, 08:40:48 pm
I'll be patient.

I mean, what sort of society do you want us to be?

I'll give you an example. I want us to be a wealthy, stable, comfortable country. I want us to deservedly have the respect of the world for our success and our tolerance. I want us to give opportunities to everyone and to look after those who hit on hard times. I want us to define ourselves by what we can do positively, not by the negatives we see in other people.

And here's a real biggie to think about during 10 years of Tory rule. This is the society that we have become after the last ten years of Tory rule.

https://mobile.twitter.com/jon_trickett/status/1208060877452300288

More than anything, I'd like the people of the post industrial North to ask themselves why this has happened, who has encouraged it, and who will help us reverse it.

I accept that's a lost cause with you, because to you it's not about who wins. It's about who loses. I truly pity that outlook. There'll be younger generations coming through in time who WILL be fired up to put this right though.