Viking Supporters Co-operative
Viking Chat => Viking Chat => Topic started by: NickDRFC on August 08, 2024, 08:45:06 pm
-
Surely we're done now with incomings*? Assuming everyone here is fit and ready, I'd go with:
TSL
Sterry Wood Olowu Maxwell
Bailey Broadbent
Molyneux Hurst Gibson
Ironside
Lawlor, McGrath, Nixon, Kelly, Sbarra, Yeboah, Sharp
This assumes McGrath covers the "home grown" quota. I'm sure the Olowu pick is controversial, especially given Anderson misses out entirely, but I feel like this could be the season that he really establishes himself and I'm always wary of the lack of pace in the Anderson/Wood pairing. I do think that Anderson will start with Wood, though. Not seen any pre-season but it feels like Broadbent has done well enough to start.
That would leave Anderson, Senior, Flint, Clifton, SSB & Westbrooke not making the squad, and Close to come back when fit. Will be some job managing the squad and morale for those that are missing out this year! And I'm probably still missing someone!
EDIT - *I guess we may still be looking to replace Miller so possibly even more decisions to make...
-
I agree with most of your selection however I think Anderson will start with Olowu on the bench and McGrath missing out.
-
Not controversial from me:
TSL
Sterry. Wood. Anderson. Maxwell
Bailey. Broadbent
Molyneux. Hurst. Gibson
Ironside
Lawlor. Olowu. Nixon. Sbarra. Yeboah. Sharp. Clifton
-
Not controversial from me:
TSL
Sterry. Wood. Anderson. Maxwell
Bailey. Broadbent
Molyneux. Hurst. Gibson
Ironside
Lawlor. Olowu. Nixon. Sbarra. Yeboah. Sharp. Clifton
It’s been mentioned before that you need a homegrown player in the squad, so one of McGrath (if he qualifies), Flint or SSB would need to be on the bench.
-
Do we know if McGrath counts? If so, Olowu would miss out.
-
Not controversial from me:
TSL
Sterry. Wood. Anderson. Maxwell
Bailey. Broadbent
Molyneux. Hurst. Gibson
Ironside
Lawlor. Olowu. Nixon. Sbarra. Yeboah. Sharp. Clifton
With Lawlor starting at Rotherham, I think he might get the nod. To be fair he did make a couple of good reaction saves. I'm no Lawlor fan but, he's just edging it for me.
-
Not controversial from me:
TSL
Sterry. Wood. Anderson. Maxwell
Bailey. Broadbent
Molyneux. Hurst. Gibson
Ironside
Lawlor. Olowu. Nixon. Sbarra. Yeboah. Sharp. Clifton
It’s been mentioned before that you need a homegrown player in the squad, so one of McGrath (if he qualifies), Flint or SSB would need to be on the bench.
It's a club developed player, which means:
‘Club Developed Player’ means a Player who has been registered with the relevant
Club for a minimum of 12 months prior to the end of his Under 19 Season (as
determined in accordance with the Youth Development Rules).
It reads like it doesn't kick in until the window has closed and talks about youth players having been sold on as being an exception, could the kids who went to man utd as an example mean it doesn't apply?
-
Surely this rule you talking about covers any club in our football association therefore any player who has been developed in any team in our football association covers the criteria
Therefore squad for Saturday
TSL
Sterry. Anderson Wood. Maxwell
Bailey. Kelly
Molyneux. Hurst. Gibson
Ironside
Lawlor. Nixon. Olowu. Broadbent. Clifton or Sbarra Yeboah. Sharp
-
I think Lawlor will start, Olowu with Anderson on the bench and Flint on the bench for the homegrown player
-
If Tom is fit, he is going to start with Wood. That’s pretty clear. Not had ideal pre-season though. I also don’t think the Chelsea lad is going to be here and sat on the bench.
-
If Tom is fit, he is going to start with Wood. That’s pretty clear. Not had ideal pre-season though. I also don’t think the Chelsea lad is going to be here and sat on the bench.
Agree with Anderson. He looked fine at Rotherham. Olowu on the bench for the switch to a back 5. McGrath as back up.
Unless Broadbent has a knock, he's surely got to start. He's earned that right in preseason and would be a smack in the mouth if Kelly went straight in. Kelly could be saved for the final flourish in the last quarter, along with Billy, Sbarra and Yeboah.
-
We have not seen a squad this strong for many a year. There is talent everywhere, including on the bench.
-
I think Lawlor will start, Olowu with Anderson on the bench and Flint on the bench for the homegrown player
Home grown player rule 34.9 either from our club or from a club in the football association.
Club developed player to be named after the transfer window closes34.12
So we will see how it’s sorted
-
Mols, Gibson Hurst looks exciting but very lightweight to me
-
We have not seen a squad this strong for many a year. There is talent everywhere, including on the bench.
It's incredible, not sure how he's going yo keep everyone happy.
I do have a feeling one of close or westbrooke will be moved on. They are in a similar position to Miller.
-
Rovers team bus for Newport
-
We have not seen a squad this strong for many a year. There is talent everywhere, including on the bench.
It's incredible, not sure how he's going yo keep everyone happy.
I do have a feeling one of close or westbrooke will be moved on. They are in a similar position to Miller.
There will be injuries no doubt. The best teams use 16 players a game now. I'm sure he's hoping he can rotate a bit and rest players at times too. You'd want to see sharp, Ironside for example at it fully for 60 mins then the other coming on and keep that tempo up.
Our downfall in the Everton game last year was that lack of a bench, we shouldn't have that problem this year. It's a much bigger squad game now than it ever has been with the 5 subs.
-
We have not seen a squad this strong for many a year. There is talent everywhere, including on the bench.
It's incredible, not sure how he's going yo keep everyone happy.
I do have a feeling one of close or westbrooke will be moved on. They are in a similar position to Miller.
Perhaps, although he gave them both new deals just a few months back.
-
We have not seen a squad this strong for many a year. There is talent everywhere, including on the bench.
It's incredible, not sure how he's going yo keep everyone happy.
I do have a feeling one of close or westbrooke will be moved on. They are in a similar position to Miller.
Perhaps, although he gave them both new deals just a few months back.
Smart move, get a transfer fee.
-
is selby still doing "let's talk about..." threads this year?
-
I think Lawlor will start, Olowu with Anderson on the bench and Flint on the bench for the homegrown player
I wouldn’t start Lawlor, also even before Flint went on loan the homegrown player was more likely to be Straughan-Brown
-
is selby still doing "let's talk about..." threads this year?
I was just thinking that. Not the same and no doubt, we'll get multiple threads on the match without it. Come on Selby, do your thing.
-
I would go…
TSL
Sterry
Anderson
Wood
Maxell
Bailey
Broadbent
Kelly
Moly
Hurst
Ironside
Subs: Lawlor, Nixon, Olowu, Gibson, Clifton, Yeboah, Sharp.
-
TSL
Maxwell
Anderson
Wood
Sterry
Broadbent
Bailey
Sbarra
Gibson
Ironside
Molyneux
-
TSL
Maxwell
Anderson
Wood8
Sterry
Broadbent
Bailey
Sbarra
Gibson
Ironside
Molyneux
Cant believe Hursty not in there after his pre-season! He would be 3rd or 4th on team sheet for me.
-
TSL
Terry Anderson Wood Maxwell
Bailey Broadbent Hurst
Molyneux Ironside Gibson
-
TSL
Terry Anderson Wood Maxwell
Bailey Broadbent Hurst
Molyneux Ironside Gibson
Mr Bramall might struggle getting up and down the right flank at his age
-
If Lawlor starts we've brought in a massive downgrade on TLT on loan
-
Got to be TSL
-
If Lawlor starts we've brought in a massive downgrade on TLT on loan
He is still finding his feet at this level of football.
It seems we have brought in potential rather than someone who has proven himself at Football League level.
He only played 2 games for Bromley last season. That’s not much experience to call on.
I hope this proves not to be a bit of a clanger.
If he isn’t good enough for a regular starting birth then he needs to get sent back to Chelsea.
I am sure there must be a clause in the deal to allow that.
Let’s give him a chance over the first 7/8 games and then see what we all think.
The keeper is so important and can be a difference of 15/20 points over a full season. That’s massive.
We saw what TLT did in those final 18 games last season.
-
Hurst has to start ahead of Sbarra.
He has earned that in pre season.
Broadbent likewise I am sure will start. He has also earned that place.
Kelly has only just arrived this week so no way do I think he will go straight into the team.
Centre back it’s 2 from 3 to start. Wood, Anderson & Olowu. Could be any combination I think. Not sure Wood is nailed on to start but suspect he probably will.
McGrath on bench or possibly not if one of the other 3 is on the bench.
Rest of team picks itself as of now imo.
Sterry, Maxwell, Bailey, Molly, Gibson, Ironside.
Come on Rovers. Let’s hit the ground running.
-
Agree Hurst must start.
Thought Lawlor looked in good form last week but TSL had better distribution. Interesting choice that one.
I'm super excited for today. I would go Ironside over sharp but will be interesting to see.
-
TSL
Terry Anderson Wood Maxwell
Bailey Broadbent Hurst
Molyneux Ironside Gibson
Mr Bramall might struggle getting up and down the right flank at his age
Great spot that nc.
Made me laugh.
Mind you, JR had a go so it isn’t without precedent.
-
TSL
Maxwell
Anderson
Wood
Sterry
Broadbent
Bailey
Sbarra
Gibson
Ironside
Molyneux
10 out of 11 right!
Hurst starts. Sbarra bench.
-
Has the requirement for one 'club developed' player in the matchday 18 lapsed?
-
Is that the strongest bench we’ve had in years!!
-
TSL
Maxwell
Anderson
Wood
Sterry
Broadbent
Bailey
Sbarra
Gibson
Ironside
Molyneux
10 out of 11 right!
Hurst starts. Sbarra bench.
11 out of 11 right in my OP :scarf:
-
Hurst far too lightweight for that position JMHO
-
Yeah I was amazed Hurst wasn’t taken off earlier
-
TSL
Terry Anderson Wood Maxwell
Bailey Broadbent Hurst
Molyneux Ironside Gibson TSL
Terry Anderson Wood Maxwell
Bailey Broadbent Hurst
Molyneux Ironside Gibson
Mr Bramall might struggle getting up and down the right flank at his age
:blush: :lol:
I got the team right though :cool: