Viking Supporters Co-operative
Viking Chat => Viking Chat => Topic started by: paddymacca on May 26, 2010, 08:36:06 pm
-
I don't care that Shackell signed for Barnsley. I don't care that Ward went to Norwich. I don't care if Sharp decides to sign for leeds or derby or whoever. What SOD has done for are club in the last 4 years or so with the budget he's had and the players he has bought. i am more than confident we will have a squad next year which will enable us to compete in the top half of the championship. Let's be realistic, we can't compete financially with most of the clubs in the championship and Blackpool proved this season that nothing is impossible.
-
well said mate.
I will go the games even irrespective of what kind of squad we have.
the club must go on. ! :)
-
the keeping of SOD at drfc far outweighs 11 billy sharps
by a country mile
-
Quite right, and the dignified and fair way he handled the brush with Burnley made his reputation even better. How many truly honest people are there in football? Not many, how lucky are we?
-
paddymacca wrote:
I don't care that Shackell signed for Barnsley. I don't care that Ward went to Norwich. I don't care if Sharp decides to sign for leeds or derby or whoever. What SOD has done for are club in the last 4 years or so with the budget he's had and the players he has bought. i am more than confident we will have a squad next year which will enable us to compete in the top half of the championship. Let's be realistic, we can't compete financially with most of the clubs in the championship and Blackpool proved this season that nothing is impossible.
I think we are getting to complacent and we are too reliant on SOD. Yes he has pulled white rabbits out the hat before, but even he cant keep on doing it with our budget as we cant compete with lower league clubs.
One day SOD will fail unless he finds another arsenal youth or ex man u player.
-
Why should he fail to get the Arsenal or United youngster when he gets the team to play as he does, JET cofirmed to the world how good it was at Rovers, Mr.Wenger doesn't forget things like that.
-
Barmby Rover wrote:
Why should he fail to get the Arsenal or United youngster when he gets the team to play as he does, JET cofirmed to the world how good it was at Rovers, Mr.Wenger doesn't forget things like that.
If you think SOD can pull it off every year then well done to you, but realistically we will become weaker and weaker. There's only so many players on the circuit.
-
In that case maybe JR and SOD ought to stop trying then and just run the squad down now! After all, we seem to get weaker every year for the last ten don't we?
-
Barmby Rover wrote:
In that case maybe JR and SOD ought to stop trying then and just run the squad down now! After all, we seem to get weaker every year for the last ten don't we?
Eh? We cant compete at this level. No one is talking about ten years ago?
The fact is, SOD is losing out on his plan (A) all of the time because we cant back him. SOD could do better than us, SIMPLE really.
-
There's only so many players on the circuit.
It's like the second hand car market. There are a few good uns out there, it's finding the right on at the right price. Wait too long and it may have gone !
I think SOD would make a good second hand car dealer !!
-
DonnyBazR0ver wrote:
There's only so many players on the circuit.
It's like the second hand car market. There are a few good uns out there, it's finding the right on at the right price. Wait too long and it may have gone !
I think SOD would make a good second hand car dealer !!
SOD has gone for many players that have impressed him over the years especially the players he has worked with elsewhere.
I just cant see him finding many more gems, and I bet he knows it. It's an impossible task here. We are on borrowed time IMHO.
-
\"We are on borrowed time IMHO\"
Another loan in then - 'time' and you said SOD had run out of options.
-
Jesus Topnotch, 'On borrowed time'?
What you been smoking mate? Can i have some please?
-
JamieM wrote:
Jesus Topnotch, 'On borrowed time'?
What you been smoking mate? Can i have some please?
I think we are on borrowed time for two reasons, keeping SOD and being relegated.
We wont be here forever.
-
Your second statement is correct. So is your first. At some point both will come true. But your assetions about their timing need some serious reasons in justification before anyone is ever likely to agree with you.
Cheers
BobG
-
BobG wrote:
Your second statement is correct. So is your first. At some point both will come true. But your assetions about their timing need some serious reasons in justification before anyone is ever likely to agree with you.
Cheers
BobG
Fair point. Just enjoy it why we are here is my message. We might even become established, but we shouldn't take it for granted.
-
topnotch_Donny wrote:
JamieM wrote:
Jesus Topnotch, 'On borrowed time'?
What you been smoking mate? Can i have some please?
I think we are on borrowed time for two reasons, keeping SOD and being relegated.
We wont be here forever.
Completely agree Bob, SOD wont be here forever but most probably JR will. Whilst JR is chairman, do you trust him to replace SOD as well as he replaced Penney?
What do you mean being on borrowed time for being relegated? Eventually we probably will be but where is the evidence that this is going to happen in the near future?
-
JamieM wrote:
topnotch_Donny wrote:
JamieM wrote:
Jesus Topnotch, 'On borrowed time'?
What you been smoking mate? Can i have some please?
I think we are on borrowed time for two reasons, keeping SOD and being relegated.
We wont be here forever.
Completely agree Bob, SOD wont be here forever but most probably JR will. Whilst JR is chairman, do you trust him to replace SOD as well as he replaced Penney?
What do you mean being on borrowed time for being relegated? Eventually we probably will be but where is the evidence that this is going to happen in the near future?
Yes borrowed time we go down, not borrowed time we will be extinct.
I just think we have been lucky thus far and SOD cant keep it up as some think he can because we did well last season.
We have become a little complacent imho.
-
topnotch_Donny wrote:
JamieM wrote:
topnotch_Donny wrote:
JamieM wrote:
Jesus Topnotch, 'On borrowed time'?
What you been smoking mate? Can i have some please?
I think we are on borrowed time for two reasons, keeping SOD and being relegated.
We wont be here forever.
Completely agree Bob, SOD wont be here forever but most probably JR will. Whilst JR is chairman, do you trust him to replace SOD as well as he replaced Penney?
What do you mean being on borrowed time for being relegated? Eventually we probably will be but where is the evidence that this is going to happen in the near future?
Yes borrowed time we go down, not borrowed time we will be extinct.
I just think we have been lucky thus far and SOD cant keep it up as some think he can because we did well last season.
We have become a little complacent imho.
I disagree, there is no evidence for us being on ''borrowed time'' or any evidence for us to be relegated next season as you are suggesting - the season only finished 3 weeks ago!
An individual suddenly doesn't lose their talents, especially an intelligent, seasoned proffesional such as our SOD. Also, he's just been given the largest budget ever for a Rovers manager.
How have we become complacent? Only on an earlier thread you were saying that you expect Rovers to be pushing for a play off place this year and now you suggest impending doom? :S
-
JamieM wrote:
topnotch_Donny wrote:
JamieM wrote:
topnotch_Donny wrote:
JamieM wrote:
Jesus Topnotch, 'On borrowed time'?
What you been smoking mate? Can i have some please?
I think we are on borrowed time for two reasons, keeping SOD and being relegated.
We wont be here forever.
Completely agree Bob, SOD wont be here forever but most probably JR will. Whilst JR is chairman, do you trust him to replace SOD as well as he replaced Penney?
What do you mean being on borrowed time for being relegated? Eventually we probably will be but where is the evidence that this is going to happen in the near future?
Yes borrowed time we go down, not borrowed time we will be extinct.
I just think we have been lucky thus far and SOD cant keep it up as some think he can because we did well last season.
We have become a little complacent imho.
I disagree, there is no evidence for us being on ''borrowed time'' or any evidence for us to be relegated next season as you are suggesting - the season only finished 3 weeks ago!
An individual suddenly doesn't lose their talents, especially an intelligent, seasoned proffesional such as our SOD. Also, he's just been given the largest budget ever for a Rovers manager.
How have we become complacent? Only on an earlier thread you were saying that you expect Rovers to be pushing for a play off place this year and now you suggest impending doom? :S
I never said we would go down next season,
And weren't Plymouth an established side? We are on borrowed time, like it or not. SOD cant pull it off everytime.
-
He can pull me off anytime he likes! :)
BobG
-
Football managers come with varing degrees of capablilities, some very good and some not so good. Sean quite obviously comes in the first category.
As we know from past experiences, the not so goods come along with more frequency than a very good managers. We've had more than our share of not so's and are very lucky to have had Sean in charge for quite some time now without too many serious approaches(that we know about) to lure him away from DRFC.
JR has every faith in Sean and has perhaps put his (& DRFC) money where his mouth is and given Sean a big enough financial incentive - wages & bonuses - to stay with us to try and push for a play-off spot next season, along with a big transfer money pot.
Sean will be with us for a good while yet, I've no doubts about it.
Now when it comes to players we all know that they come as all things from hopeless to excellent. The hopeless ones are normally freed out of the club and the excellent ones can either be tempted away by bigger bucks and big promises by any club who cares to wave the wonga. They can either remain an excellent player for their new club or become an average to good player as they are overshadowed by other more excellent players in the squad. What I am trying to get at is that players in the main are mercenary when it comes to money and some don't have any scruples about chasing the money. On the other hand, we have a manager who is doing a grand job, for what is probably one of the lower salaries in the Championship, but remains loyal to the club because he knows that the true supporters who pay a big whack every week to see his team play have the faith in him to continue to do a really good job. As does his Chairman and Board of Directors.
Also he commands the respect of his squad, and that is the most important part of being a manager, not only in football but in all walks of life.
Sean was at Bournemouth for over 20 years as player then manager, there's no reason why he couldn't stay here at DRFC for any great length of time. Why leave a set-up that he's nurtured to become a successful club and go somewhere that the players couldn't settle into his style of management and possibly cause him to lose that job? What would he do then? Become one of football's journeymen managers like Harry Redknapp or several others?
-
I never said we would go down next season,
And weren't Plymouth an established side? We are on borrowed time, like it or not. SOD cant pull it off everytime.
You were implying that we were to go down soon and no they were not an established side, they finished 21st the season before this one.
You keep saying that were on borrowed time over and over again, but where is your argument, where is your evidence for this?
Or is it really just mindless drivel?
-
The way I see it is that the club can't afford to make many mistakes at this level. Other clubs can get away with a few bad signings, or a bad managerial appointment (or bad marketing B) ) because they have the cash to try and repair the mistake. We don't have that luxury.
Every decision counts. Both JR and SOD have had a very nice little streak of good fortune/brilliant decision making recently. I'm enjoying watching it unfold and also hoping that as many clubs as I think, will be getting a points reduction next season which may level the playing field a little.
-
JamieM wrote:
I never said we would go down next season,
And weren't Plymouth an established side? We are on borrowed time, like it or not. SOD cant pull it off everytime.
You were implying that we were to go down soon and no they were not an established side, they finished 21st the season before this one.
You keep saying that were on borrowed time over and over again, but where is your argument, where is your evidence for this?
Or is it really just mindless drivel?
Plymouth were at this level a bloody long time. Even Rotherham enjoyed six years at this level. We are on borrowed time, it is as simple as that. We cant live with teams at this level. so there will come a time when we plummet.
SOD might have pulled white rabbits before, but he is losing player a for player b then player c, and there becomes a point where you become stuck. That or lose your manager.
I think we are league one size, so I am just enjoying it and we will go down Be it next season or another 5 seasons.
-
topnotch_Donny wrote:
JamieM wrote:
I never said we would go down next season,
And weren't Plymouth an established side? We are on borrowed time, like it or not. SOD cant pull it off everytime.
You were implying that we were to go down soon and no they were not an established side, they finished 21st the season before this one.
You keep saying that were on borrowed time over and over again, but where is your argument, where is your evidence for this?
Or is it really just mindless drivel?
Plymouth were at this level a bloody long time. Even Rotherham enjoyed six years at this level. We are on borrowed time, it is as simple as that. We cant live with teams at this level. so there will come a time when we plummet.
SOD might have pulled white rabbits before, but he is losing player a for player b then player c, and there becomes a point where you become stuck. That or lose your manager.
I think we are league one size, so I am just enjoying it and we will go down Be it next season or another 5 seasons.
You aren't related to Private Fraser are you? (We're doomed, we're doomed) :whistle:
-
Your team are only as good as your next season. :ohmy:
-
Old Popsider wrote:
Football managers come with varing degrees of capablilities, some very good and some not so good. Sean quite obviously comes in the first category.
As we know from past experiences, the not so goods come along with more frequency than a very good managers. We've had more than our share of not so's and are very lucky to have had Sean in charge for quite some time now without too many serious approaches(that we know about) to lure him away from DRFC.
JR has every faith in Sean and has perhaps put his (& DRFC) money where his mouth is and given Sean a big enough financial incentive - wages & bonuses - to stay with us to try and push for a play-off spot next season, along with a big transfer money pot.
Sean will be with us for a good while yet, I've no doubts about it.
Now when it comes to players we all know that they come as all things from hopeless to excellent. The hopeless ones are normally freed out of the club and the excellent ones can either be tempted away by bigger bucks and big promises by any club who cares to wave the wonga. They can either remain an excellent player for their new club or become an average to good player as they are overshadowed by other more excellent players in the squad. What I am trying to get at is that players in the main are mercenary when it comes to money and some don't have any scruples about chasing the money. On the other hand, we have a manager who is doing a grand job, for what is probably one of the lower salaries in the Championship, but remains loyal to the club because he knows that the true supporters who pay a big whack every week to see his team play have the faith in him to continue to do a really good job. As does his Chairman and Board of Directors.
Also he commands the respect of his squad, and that is the most important part of being a manager, not only in football but in all walks of life.
Sean was at Bournemouth for over 20 years as player then manager, there's no reason why he couldn't stay here at DRFC for any great length of time. Why leave a set-up that he's nurtured to become a successful club and go somewhere that the players couldn't settle into his style of management and possibly cause him to lose that job? What would he do then? Become one of football's journeymen managers like Harry Redknapp or several others?
When I read quotes likes yours I have to have a little chuckle.
SOD like every other football manager if offered the right salary will be off. Its nothing to do with loyalty it is common sense.
Football Managers are no different to the rest of us.
For those lucky enough to enjoy the work we do would also surely move on to another company if they were prepared to give us a sizeable increase in salary.
As for becoming a journeyman like Harry Redknapp. Poor old Harry!! I wish I was such a journeyman.
-
If the terms are better and a bigger club comes in he wont think twice if he gets the chance.
WOULD YOU?
-
I defy anyone on here to say they wouldn't go.
Of course I would go.
-
topnotch_Donny wrote:
Plymouth were at this level a bloody long time. Even Rotherham enjoyed six years at this level. We are on borrowed time, it is as simple as that. We cant live with teams at this level. so there will come a time when we plummet.
SOD might have pulled white rabbits before, but he is losing player a for player b then player c, and there becomes a point where you become stuck. That or lose your manager.
I think we are league one size, so I am just enjoying it and we will go down Be it next season or another 5 seasons.
Yes we can live with teams in this division, we have shown that time and again over the past 2 seasons.
However, we can't compete financially in this division but that doesn't mean that we're on borrowed time. Yes SOD has lost out on players but they will be replaced, do you not think he has a plan B, C, D, E? I think your underestimating him to be honest. Remember, we have 10 weeks to get new players!
There may be a day where we can compete, with steadily rising attendances over the next couple of years, who knows. Instead of competing in the 'Championship' transfer market we wheel and deal in the upper League 1 and 2 markets, the lower SPL market, the cheap European market and particularly utilise the loan market.
-
Surely Blackpool have just shown exactly how much we should be panicking in the predicament we're in.
We're likely to spend more than they did last summer and on the back of some brilliant loan dealings and good management from Holloway they've got to the supposed promised land.
There's nothing to say the same can't be done by DRFC with a lot of luck and a following wind - even if the unthinkable happened and SoD was to be tempted away, again, imagine how many Blackpool fans thought they'd move forward when Grayson jumped ship to manage that big club up the road.
Don't panic people for crying out loud we're in good hands.
-
The way I see it is, SOD cant buy top quality players as they are out of our price range, so he goes for loan and bosman players as we cant compete with fees.
Sod is losing out in player chioce A). Ok he has plan b,c,d and e, but do you think his choice E) will be as good as his choice B)?
I think we become weaker every time SOD misses out on his target hence me saying, its only a matter off time before we become stuck. Yes, SOD has worked miracles in the last two seasons, but that doesn't mean he will always pull it off, does it?
And Blackpool were a fairytale story. I cant see any small club emulating them anytime soon.
All I am saying is, enjoy this level as our time will come and we will face the drop, and we all know how long and how hard it can be to get back up :X
-
topnotch_Donny wrote:
The way I see it is, SOD cant buy top quality players as they are out of our price range, so he goes for loan and bosman players as we cant compete with fees.
Sod is losing out in player chioce A). Ok he has plan b,c,d and e, but do you think his choice E) will be as good as his choice B)?
I think we become weaker every time SOD misses out on his target hence me saying, its only a matter off time before we become stuck. Yes, SOD has worked miracles in the last two seasons, but that doesn't mean he will always pull it off, does it?
How can you say we become weaker? We have improved every season he has been here. How does that make us weaker?
Plus, if he keeps pulling it off. He will have eyes likes 'Master' off Kung Fu
-
CusworthRovers wrote:
topnotch_Donny wrote:
The way I see it is, SOD cant buy top quality players as they are out of our price range, so he goes for loan and bosman players as we cant compete with fees.
Sod is losing out in player chioce A). Ok he has plan b,c,d and e, but do you think his choice E) will be as good as his choice B)?
I think we become weaker every time SOD misses out on his target hence me saying, its only a matter off time before we become stuck. Yes, SOD has worked miracles in the last two seasons, but that doesn't mean he will always pull it off, does it?
How can you say we become weaker? We have improved every season he has been here. How does that make us weaker?
Plus, if he keeps pulling it off. He will have eyes likes 'Master' off Kung Fu
Did we become stronger? It's hard to tell i guess. Some say and I agree that if we had have kept Wellens and Mills we would have done better.
Its panic season I guess :P
-
You haven't answered why we've become weaker, and simply asked me if we have become stronger.
I'll give you the courtesy of answering your question..............yes we have got stronger. Season 1 outside play offs plus JPT. Season 2 promoted. Season 3 stayed in CCC and finished mid table. Season 4 finished 12th.
I suppose you can only judge how strong we are on the pitch by points and league. We have got stronger every season.
Off the pitch, all the right noises are coming out that we are not struggling unlike all.
To summarise, I would suggest we have got stronger each season under Sean.
So, how are we weaker then, in your opinion?
-
Billy Sharp was why we got more points. I think we were actually weaker last season than the season before. Our first season at this level, we were struggling with confidence (for the first half of the season) but then we flew.
This season that's just gone, we have been steady, and never came close to what we were in the second half of the first season.
If we could keep hold of players, we would be very strong; however, we cant, so we have to start again hence getting weaker. Lets see what the next chapter reveals as I think we will struggle.
Just a gut feeling.I hope I am wrong, but it's getting harder and harder imho. You cant maintain a CCC side if you lose key players all the time, it's destructive to the progression and there's only so many times SOD can fix it :laugh:
-
topnotch_Donny wrote:
Billy Sharp was why we got more points. I think we were actually weaker last season than the season before. Our first season at this level, we were struggling with confidence (for the first half of the season) but then we flew.
This season that's just gone, we have been steady, and never came close to what we were in the second half of the first season.
If we could keep hold of players, we would be very strong; however, we cant, so we have to start again hence getting weaker. Lets see what the next chapter reveals as I think we will struggle.
Just a gut feeling.I hope I am wrong, but it's getting harder and harder imho. You cant maintain a CCC side if you lose key players all the time, it's destructive to the progression and there's only so many times SOD can fix it :laugh:
Theres no doubting the loss of Mills and Wellens appeared to weaken us on paper. But we did better in terms of points and position. So IMO thats all you need to say to say we were stronger. We never dropped into the releagtion zones and at one time we were 5 points off the playoffs with a game in hand.
I totally agree its getting harder and there aren't many small teams at this level like there have been in recent seasons but if we renew all outstanding contracts and get in 3/4 loan signings of similar quality to this season then (plus the now mentioned quality striker) then I think we're set for a similar season to last.
-
Yes we got more points last season because we were low on confidence in the first half of the first season.
I bet we would have got more points last season with the team that finished the first season hence being weaker :laugh:
I'm guessing obviously, but we just started to click and then lost key players and we have never hit the same form since.
-
I think that the footballing community watch what little gems O'Driscoll uncovers and if we can't be quick about signing them up when they become available there are plenty of vultures ready to take advantage.
-
topnotch_Donny wrote:
Yes we got more points last season because we were low on confidence in the first half of the first season.
I bet we would have got more points last season with the team that finished the first season hence being weaker :laugh:
I'm guessing obviously, but we just started to click and then lost key players and we have never hit the same form since.
Its hard to pass hypothetical judgements on mental traits carrying on through a season with regards to confidence but remember we actually finished last season with 15pts from the last 12 games so hardly flying form.
And taking it at \"ins and outs\" level:
Shackell more than replaced Mills.
Sharp & JET improved the team.
Oster didn't replace Wellens in a like for like sense but added as much quality in the middle.
So whilst we could never prove it, I wouldn't go along with your bet, especially factoring in the general improvement of players this season like JOC, Roberts, Wilson, Shiels.
-
DRNaith wrote:
I think that the footballing community watch what little gems O'Driscoll uncovers and if we can't be quick about signing them up when they become available there are plenty of vultures ready to take advantage.
Very true. In loaning players its almost like doing other clubs scouting for them - they see how they perform on loan here and then swoop in if they make the grade.
If I were a scout at any club around us in the final table (Preston, Derby, Coventry) I'd be keeping an eye on anyone doing well for us and coming up to the end of contract.
-
DonnyNoel wrote:
topnotch_Donny wrote:
Yes we got more points last season because we were low on confidence in the first half of the first season.
I bet we would have got more points last season with the team that finished the first season hence being weaker :laugh:
I'm guessing obviously, but we just started to click and then lost key players and we have never hit the same form since.
Its hard to pass hypothetical judgements on mental traits carrying on through a season with regards to confidence but remember we actually finished last season with 15pts from the last 12 games so hardly flying form.
And taking it at \"ins and outs\" level:
Shackell more than replaced Mills.
Sharp & JET improved the team.
Oster didn't replace Wellens in a like for like sense but added as much quality in the middle.
So whilst we could never prove it, I wouldn't go along with your bet, especially factoring in the general improvement of players this season like JOC, Roberts, Wilson, Shiels.
We have never hit the form of the 2nd half of the 1st season, and we only picked up 2 more points than the season before (last season) and that was with all of Billies goals and a steady season with no real dips, like we had when we first came up, in a time were SOD was learning about the division.
If you can remember, we were creating some real good chances,but no one could finish the chances. We were also a bit too slow in the build up.
As soon as we upped the pace and brought on a natural finisher, we picked up the 2ND most points in the division in the 2ND half of the season (form we haven't come close to repeating since).
I think at the start of this season there was confidence in the squad because they realised that they could do it, as shown in the 2ND half of the first season.
Anyway it's pointless guessing, so fingers crossed that SOD works his magic again.
It's about time we had a bit of good news though :P
-
DonnyNoel wrote:
DRNaith wrote:
I think that the footballing community watch what little gems O'Driscoll uncovers and if we can't be quick about signing them up when they become available there are plenty of vultures ready to take advantage.
Very true. In loaning players its almost like doing other clubs scouting for them - they see how they perform on loan here and then swoop in if they make the grade.
If I were a scout at any club around us in the final table (Preston, Derby, Coventry) I'd be keeping an eye on anyone doing well for us and coming up to the end of contract.
Yes that's the price of success, we become a bargain bin for bigger clubs.
JR can try and beat them off with a stick, but money talks :X