Viking Supporters Co-operative

Viking Chat => Viking Chat => Rate the Ref => Topic started by: The Red Baron on August 20, 2017, 09:40:55 am

Title: Rovers v Hull City. Carabao Cup - 22/8/17- Eddie Ilderton
Post by: The Red Baron on August 20, 2017, 09:40:55 am
Referee: Eddie Ilderton.
Assistants: Alf Greenwood & Michael Denton.
4th: Sebastian Stockbridge.
Title: Re: Rovers v Hull City. Carabao Cup - 22/8/17- Graham Salisbury
Post by: robchester on August 22, 2017, 09:47:59 pm
Had a decent game
Title: Re: Rovers v Hull City. Carabao Cup - 22/8/17- Graham Salisbury
Post by: glosterred on August 22, 2017, 10:32:24 pm
So much better than the idiot last Saturday but did make one glaring error when, I think it was Whitemans, free kick was tipped over. Despite the Lino signalling for a corner he gave a goal kick. Other than that a good game.

COYR
Title: Re: Rovers v Hull City. Carabao Cup - 22/8/17- Graham Salisbury
Post by: POD on August 22, 2017, 10:43:16 pm
I'm not sure that it was Graham Salisbury?   You may remember that he was the ref for the League Cup 2nd Round tie in 2005 against Manchester City ... Perhaps an omen here,  but as I say, it didn't look like him out there tonight.
Title: Re: Rovers v Hull City. Carabao Cup - 22/8/17- Graham Salisbury
Post by: Filo on August 22, 2017, 11:16:38 pm
Decent performance from the ref, missed an obvious corner for us when their keeper made a good save
Title: Re: Rovers v Hull City. Carabao Cup - 22/8/17- Graham Salisbury
Post by: The Red Baron on August 23, 2017, 08:20:39 am
It was Eddie Ilderton. I'll change the first post
Title: Re: Rovers v Hull City. Carabao Cup - 22/8/17- Eddie Ilderton
Post by: Donnywolf on August 23, 2017, 08:37:36 am
Totally different performance to his last 2 trips here - probably aided by it being a Hull U23 side and perhaps they are not as cynical as "Div 1 professionals"

Had I been their keeper I would have chased him right back to the half way line to give Rovers a corner. What a save that was !

So I will jump to the heady heights of 3 ! I wont hold my breath that he has improved THAT much though
Title: Re: Rovers v Hull City. Carabao Cup - 22/8/17- Eddie Ilderton
Post by: drfchound on August 23, 2017, 10:06:39 am
A 4 from me.
What a difference it made to have a good ref, despite missing the top save by their keeper from Whitemans free kick.
Title: Re: Rovers v Hull City. Carabao Cup - 22/8/17- Eddie Ilderton
Post by: Donnywolf on August 25, 2017, 02:36:52 pm
Bloody hell 3.78+ at the moment - that must be 2.75 higher than last time he reffed us AND the time before ! Just looked back (see below) and he actually got 0.74 and 0.29 so I was right exactly
 higher than last 2 visits !

Cant believe he just woke up one morning recently and just "got it"



This is what I posted last time :

Looking back at when we last had him he scored 31 Points from 42 votes (which is bad in itself) which gave an average score of .74. There were 29 x Nils !
To date for yesterdays "performance" he has only 7 points from 24 Votes of which 18 are "nil" votes and that average is a mere 0.29 !

Nevertheless the Refs Assessor (who was the West Stand Lino) will have given him 87 out of a 100 and the Ref (who dishes out the scores for them) will have given the Lino 81 out of 100)
Modify message