0 Members and 1 Guest are viewing this topic.
Quote from: Campsall rover on September 28, 2024, 07:22:31 pmBailey and Kelly as the 2 in front of back 4 If Close is going to start he has to play further forward because he can’t defend. Last week he was good, this week awful.We mis Mathew Craig the most imo He simply has not been replacedSbarra is a talented player but lacks physicality for this league. Thought Chesterfield were just better than us all over the pitch.We need to get the middle of the park sorted. That’s where our weakness are most evident..Sbarra you'd have in your 5 a side team, but not in men's football
Bailey and Kelly as the 2 in front of back 4 If Close is going to start he has to play further forward because he can’t defend. Last week he was good, this week awful.We mis Mathew Craig the most imo He simply has not been replacedSbarra is a talented player but lacks physicality for this league. Thought Chesterfield were just better than us all over the pitch.We need to get the middle of the park sorted. That’s where our weakness are most evident..
It's not incompetence. If it was, he would be equally incompetent in his decision-making for both teams. Today he gave Chesterfield everything and Donny nothing. That looked to me like partiality to put it very mildly.
Ignore the ref?!Are you serious?!That’s like saying “apart from the tsunami we experienced during our holiday in Indonesia which killed 200,000 people we actually had quite a pleasant time”.
Quote from: DonnyOsmond on September 28, 2024, 05:24:07 pmQuote from: coventryrover on September 28, 2024, 05:15:42 pmYes he was poor but can anyone think we deserved anything from that.The game may have ended up differently with a normal referee. There was at least 3 massive game defining moments and lots of smaller ones which stopped any momentum from us.Which big decision did he get 100% wrong? The first red was nailed on, he handled it for the penalty and the second red could well have been right. Got some of the small decisions wrong admittedly.
Quote from: coventryrover on September 28, 2024, 05:15:42 pmYes he was poor but can anyone think we deserved anything from that.The game may have ended up differently with a normal referee. There was at least 3 massive game defining moments and lots of smaller ones which stopped any momentum from us.
Yes he was poor but can anyone think we deserved anything from that.
Quote from: GazLaz on September 28, 2024, 05:28:41 pmQuote from: DonnyOsmond on September 28, 2024, 05:24:07 pmQuote from: coventryrover on September 28, 2024, 05:15:42 pmYes he was poor but can anyone think we deserved anything from that.From where I was sat, some 30 yards away with Yeboah facing me, it hits the top of his standing foot then bounces up onto his arm which is in a ‘natural position’ but he had no time to move it anyway before the ball bounced up at him. The circus clown dressed in black was stood behind Yeboah so didn’t have a good view to give such a massive decision.Never a penalty in my opinion.The game may have ended up differently with a normal referee. There was at least 3 massive game defining moments and lots of smaller ones which stopped any momentum from us.Which big decision did he get 100% wrong? The first red was nailed on, he handled it for the penalty and the second red could well have been right. Got some of the small decisions wrong admittedly. That penalty decision was a shocker. Yeboah had seen the ball very late as it's cleared the jumping players ahead of him. It's bounced awkwardly and hit his arm in a perfectly natural position. He may just have moved his arm 2-3 inches instinctively as the ball dropped and bounced, but the ball would have still hit him if he hadn't. There was no advantage lost to Chesterfield as many Yeboah was marking wasn't in any position to win the ball.It's ridiculous to give a penalty for that.
Quote from: DonnyOsmond on September 28, 2024, 05:24:07 pmQuote from: coventryrover on September 28, 2024, 05:15:42 pmYes he was poor but can anyone think we deserved anything from that.From where I was sat, some 30 yards away with Yeboah facing me, it hits the top of his standing foot then bounces up onto his arm which is in a ‘natural position’ but he had no time to move it anyway before the ball bounced up at him. The circus clown dressed in black was stood behind Yeboah so didn’t have a good view to give such a massive decision.Never a penalty in my opinion.The game may have ended up differently with a normal referee. There was at least 3 massive game defining moments and lots of smaller ones which stopped any momentum from us.Which big decision did he get 100% wrong? The first red was nailed on, he handled it for the penalty and the second red could well have been right. Got some of the small decisions wrong admittedly.
Quote from: coventryrover on September 28, 2024, 05:15:42 pmYes he was poor but can anyone think we deserved anything from that.From where I was sat, some 30 yards away with Yeboah facing me, it hits the top of his standing foot then bounces up onto his arm which is in a ‘natural position’ but he had no time to move it anyway before the ball bounced up at him. The circus clown dressed in black was stood behind Yeboah so didn’t have a good view to give such a massive decision.Never a penalty in my opinion.The game may have ended up differently with a normal referee. There was at least 3 massive game defining moments and lots of smaller ones which stopped any momentum from us.
We might of been crap, but the ref was shocking, had the responsibility to Referee a big game, be fair and blew it, he might want to consider stepping down to Sunday League level along with the linesmen! He might as well have come on wearing a Chesterfield jersey. All Chesterfield had to do was turn up yesterday.
Quote from: GazLaz on September 28, 2024, 05:28:41 pmQuote from: DonnyOsmond on September 28, 2024, 05:24:07 pmQuote from: coventryrover on September 28, 2024, 05:15:42 pmYes he was poor but can anyone think we deserved anything from that.The game may have ended up differently with a normal referee. There was at least 3 massive game defining moments and lots of smaller ones which stopped any momentum from us.Which big decision did he get 100% wrong? The first red was nailed on, he handled it for the penalty and the second red could well have been right. Got some of the small decisions wrong admittedly. Well , everyone I spoke to at Half time said the Free kick which led to their Goal was NOT a foulEveryone I've spoken to said McGrath made a robust but fair challengeNeither of those were trivial decisions and nor was their forward following through on Teddy when the ball was long gone and which it seemed didn't warrant a Card in a game where every foul we did DID result in Yellow or it appeared that way
I'm surprised no one has mentioned our penalty appeal for hand ball.After having given a very very soft penalty against us there was a shot in second half when we were 2.0 down and from where I was sat it looked like their defender almost dived and saved it! That said I was quite far away so might not have been that bad!
Quote from: Ryaldinhio on September 29, 2024, 09:56:34 amI'm surprised no one has mentioned our penalty appeal for hand ball.After having given a very very soft penalty against us there was a shot in second half when we were 2.0 down and from where I was sat it looked like their defender almost dived and saved it! That said I was quite far away so might not have been that bad!I was in the south and can’t really remember any real appeals for handball
Just watched the Man Utd game and it was an exact replica of our game yesterday but without the shite referee.