0 Members and 1 Guest are viewing this topic.
wellens has had hes day
Quote from: DRFCBRADFORD on July 23, 2013, 03:41:37 pmwellens has had hes dayNonsense
He's same age as gerrard, who's just signed a new contract with Liverpool. He played week in week out for Leicester until he got injured, 2 years ago he won Leicesters player of the year and was their captain
Quote from: dickos1 on July 23, 2013, 04:23:57 pmHe's same age as gerrard, who's just signed a new contract with Liverpool. He played week in week out for Leicester until he got injured, 2 years ago he won Leicesters player of the year and was their captainWhat the fook has this got to do with Gerrard? You present some bizarre logic at times.
Quote from: Phoenix on July 23, 2013, 04:27:50 pmQuote from: dickos1 on July 23, 2013, 04:23:57 pmHe's same age as gerrard, who's just signed a new contract with Liverpool. He played week in week out for Leicester until he got injured, 2 years ago he won Leicesters player of the year and was their captainWhat the fook has this got to do with Gerrard? You present some bizarre logic at times.The logic is the players are the same age. Some folks are claiming Wellens is past it at 33, whereas lots of players aren't so why not Wellens?We're not comparing his talent to that of Gerrard, just his age and ability to maintain his current level of play.
Your argument was he's 33 so too old, obviously 33 is not too old.
No, the original post stated he'd had his day, which to me implies he's passed it, you backed this up by saying he was 33. Age is totally irrelevant,
Quote from: dickos1 on July 23, 2013, 04:40:01 pmNo, the original post stated he'd had his day, which to me implies he's passed it, you backed this up by saying he was 33. Age is totally irrelevant,I interpret "had his day" to mean "past his peak" which I said stands to reason, because how many midfielders are at their peak at 33?I didn't say he DEFINITELY had had his day in my opinion, but I said that at 33, it is not "nonsense" to suggest so, like you said. I also backed it up by saying that many Leicester fans, who have watched the guy play for the past four years, have seen a significant decline in his ability to play at this level, but I notice you have chosen to ignore that.I bring you back to a point in the previous post that you also chose to ignore... IS STEVEN GERRARD AT HIS PEAK, NOW, AT 33? Is he? Your point is that it is "nonsense" to suggest that Wellens is past his peak at 33, because Steven Gerrard is 33.... IS STEVEN GERRARD AT HIS PEAK? Is he as good as he was when he was in his 20's when he almost single-handedly dragged Liverpool back from the dead to win the European Cup final? I never disputed that Gerrard, or Wellens weren't still capable players at 33 years old... but it is not "nonsense" to suggest that they are no longer at their peak.Bloody hell. I can't spell it out any clearer than that, it's like pulling teeth on here sometimes.
Quote from: Phoenix on July 23, 2013, 04:46:34 pmQuote from: dickos1 on July 23, 2013, 04:40:01 pmNo, the original post stated he'd had his day, which to me implies he's passed it, you backed this up by saying he was 33. Age is totally irrelevant,I interpret "had his day" to mean "past his peak" which I said stands to reason, because how many midfielders are at their peak at 33?I didn't say he DEFINITELY had had his day in my opinion, but I said that at 33, it is not "nonsense" to suggest so, like you said. I also backed it up by saying that many Leicester fans, who have watched the guy play for the past four years, have seen a significant decline in his ability to play at this level, but I notice you have chosen to ignore that.I bring you back to a point in the previous post that you also chose to ignore... IS STEVEN GERRARD AT HIS PEAK, NOW, AT 33? Is he? Your point is that it is "nonsense" to suggest that Wellens is past his peak at 33, because Steven Gerrard is 33.... IS STEVEN GERRARD AT HIS PEAK? Is he as good as he was when he was in his 20's when he almost single-handedly dragged Liverpool back from the dead to win the European Cup final? I never disputed that Gerrard, or Wellens weren't still capable players at 33 years old... but it is not "nonsense" to suggest that they are no longer at their peak.Bloody hell. I can't spell it out any clearer than that, it's like pulling teeth on here sometimes.Are you on a wind up, Steve wonder would come to the conclusion that a 33 year old is not at their peak. Doesn't mean they're passed it, like monk has said there's numerous examples of players who adapt their game to be just as successful as they ever were.Anyhow end of the day I think he'd be a great signing you obviously don't, only one way we'll find out
Remind me what oldhams fans view of wellens were when we signed him, also their views on furman, preston fans view on stock, sheff utds on sharp, leeds on painter, leeds on Sullivan, Wednesday on jones, Do you want me to keep going??
Quote from: dickos1 on July 23, 2013, 05:06:13 pmRemind me what oldhams fans view of wellens were when we signed him, also their views on furman, preston fans view on stock, sheff utds on sharp, leeds on painter, leeds on Sullivan, Wednesday on jones, Do you want me to keep going??Brilliant post, it happens at every club last year a lot of people slated gillet, went on to play every game for Forrest and linked to premiership clubs! Wellens is one of the best passers of the ball I've seen in a rovers shirt!
Quote from: dickos1 on July 23, 2013, 05:06:13 pmRemind me what oldhams fans view of wellens were when we signed him, also their views on furman, preston fans view on stock, sheff utds on sharp, leeds on painter, leeds on Sullivan, Wednesday on jones, Do you want me to keep going??Can you read?I did just type before something along the lines of: "despite Leicester fans views on RW, he may be adequate for us", didn't I?FWIW, I can't remember that much negativity (beyond the usual) about Wellens from the Oldham fans when he signed for us. Nor PNE with Stock, or Leeds fans with Sullivan (the only negativity I remember about Sully was from Dennis Wise). And Wednesday fans absolutely loved Rob Jones. Sheff United told us that Sharp didn't suit them as he was trying too hard to score for his boyhood team, not that he was a bad player.This is getting ridiculous anyway. It's gone totally beyond the original point. Bye!