Billy Sharp

[Bentley Bullet]

BST

TO acknowledge that Sharp and Robinson had similar scoring records that season is testimony to Sharp, considering how much more attention he got in terms of being marked by opponents.

Put it another way. Who would you rather see play for the opposition, Sharp or Robinson?

Regarding your other point, I believe he thrives as a big fish in a small pond - and past statistics seem to reflect this.

[PopStander]

Billy Sharp was a absolute hero for us, his last spell wasn't good.

I wouldn't have him back, it would only tarnish his reputation with us.

Williams and Tyson over Sharp for me.

[BillyStubbsTears]

BB

It's a non-question. It depends which Sharp and Robinson you are talking about.

Sharp from 4 years ago and Robinson last season makes it a no-brainer. Sharp of course.

Sharp and Robinson in 13/14? Robinson for me. He scored as frequently and contributed more to the team.