Rovers v Charlton Athletic - 2/3/19 - Ben Toner

[The Red Baron]

Referee: Ben Toner
Assistants:  Graeme Fyvie & Alan Clayton
4O: David Avent

[Filo]

Disgraceful decisionfrom the west stand lino, should never ever run a line again!

[glosterred]

Don’t think he ref had too badder a game, let down by the west stand Lino with some very poor offside decisions


COYR

[Filo]

Don’t think he ref had too badder a game, let down by the west stand Lino with some very poor offside decisions


COYR

The one where blair broke clear was 3 yards onside

[glosterred]

Don’t think he ref had too badder a game, let down by the west stand Lino with some very poor offside decisions


COYR

The one where blair broke clear was 3 yards onside

Clearly onside he was shocking

[ZiggerZagger]

Decent ref, two shocking linesman, both got major decisions wrong

[roversdude]

Ref wasn’t bad unfortunately badly let down by his pals

[drfchound]

When the ref blew the final whistle I think I am right in saying that he was surrounded by lots of our players.
May jumped in at him and I think he was booked for something he said.
Also I think he booked Wilks as well.

[Filo]

When the ref blew the final whistle I think I am right in saying that he was surrounded by lots of our players.
May jumped in at him and I think he was booked for something he said.
Also I think he booked Wilks as well.

And McAnn

[The Red Baron]

The referee was very good. The assistants were atrocious.

[TheFunk]

Malik was very lucky not to get booked before. Whilst booking McCann Malik was walking and looking at the lino and repeatedly saying to the lino Cheat, cheat,cheat.

[POD]

The referee today was excellent.  He let the game flow and didn’t caution anyone in normal time.  He was able to judge when players were going down too easily and got most decisions right.  I liked the way that he dealt with JM (who must be a nightmare for referees with his constant whinging) by calling him over for a chat and a warning.  It was unfortunate that he was let down by his linesman at the end.  Perhaps he should not have played 5mins 30secs of extra time as the ‘goal’ went in when he had only given 3 minutes. Who would be a referee?

[Donnywolf]

Yes but to be fair he even got that right because the whole of the first minute of "added time" was spent on the injury to their bloke in North West corner. (Its time for the fixed 30 minutes each way to come into operation and kill all speculation). I think they brought on a Sub as well in added time so that is supposed to be 30 seconds as well

Ref had a decent game and when he spotted a hand ball on East Stand line I decided to give my 3rd 3 Points in the last 4 games - but then came the fiasco of the disallowed goal. However that was down to the Lino - and indeed he was amazingly poor. I think the Wilks goal looked dodgy because as others pointed out JM looked to be in an offside position AND he jumped over the ball

So Refs 3 Muppet(s) Nil

[drfchound]

Wolfie, there were actually two “injuries” to Charlton players during the three minutes of add on time as well as the substitution.
Playing the five and a half minutes over was justified.

As a point of interest though, the first half only the customary one minute added on even though the was a further Charlton injury which lasted for just under two minutes.

[Donnywolf]

Anyone know who the duff Linesman was from these two

Referee: Ben Toner
Assistants:  Graeme Fyvie & Alan Clayton
4O: David Avent

[The Red Baron]

They both got big decisions wrong, but Fyvie was the one who inexplicably gave May offside.