Favourite 3

[graingrover]

Alick J , Bert Tindill , James Coppinger .All three  not just very talented but Donny Rovers through and through .

[Campsall rover]

That is such a desperately difficult question.

So just ahead of quite a few others.

Ian Snodin
Glynn Snodin
Peter Kitchen

[Canadian Rover]

Billy, Copps & JJ Price.

[Chris the Rover]

King Alick, Copps and Ian Snodin

[bigbadjack]

Today it’s
Sutherland
Brabin
Mcindoe

[mushRTID]

Stock
Blundell
Sharp

[tyke1962]

I've noticed Mcindoe's name has been nominated by several posters on this thread .

So , how come you let him sign for us in 2006 for a knock down £120k ?

It's a genuine question btw .

[MachoMadness]

Sharp, Copps, Sullivan. Its a tough one though.

I've noticed Mcindoe's name has been nominated by several posters on this thread .

So , how come you let him sign for us in 2006 for a knock down £120k ?

It's a genuine question btw .

Long story short he fell out with our manager at the time and got shipped out in short order. He wasn't the only one around that time either.

[Campsall rover]

I've noticed Mcindoe's name has been nominated by several posters on this thread .

So , how come you let him sign for us in 2006 for a knock down £120k ?

It's a genuine question btw .

Because we sell most of our best players too cheaply.  Probably is the answer. Seriously good left winger.
The best we have had in my time watching Rovers.
Cotterill, also very good & Glynn Snodin when he played same position in a 4-4-2  He alternated between left midfield and left back.
On the right hand side, Ian Miller, John Buckley and Copps are the outstanding players imo.

[Copps is Magic]

Coppinger
Sharp
Blundell.

In that order.

[belton rover]

G. Snodin, Jason Price, Billy Sharp.

[Prez]

Copps
Geeen
Andy Rhodes

Sub Billy Sharp.

[dickos1]

Can’t understand anyone not including coppinger

[andyst79]

It's hard not to pick Copps but the question is favourite not best.

[Campsall rover]

Can’t understand anyone not including coppinger

Favourite player. I don’t see why Copps should be in everyone’s top 3
He would get in my top 5 definitely.

[scawsby steve]

Harry Gregg
Alick Jeffrey
Bert Tindall

Well, you bugger, Geronimo, you've just started posting and straight away you've stole my thunder.

I was just about to post the same three. Great minds and all that. Also, you'll soon get used to my pedantry. It's "Tindill", not "Tindall".

Wey hey.

[Draytonian III]

Colin Douglas
Ian Snodin
Paul Heffernan

[Super Colin Cramb]

Copps
John Marquis
Colin Cramb

[Peebles Rover]

Very good question

1. Copps
2. Ian Snodin
3. Animal

[richtherover]

King Alick
Laurie Sheffield
Peter Kitchen

[Branton Rover]

Alan Warboys
James Coppinger
Colin Douglas

[Branton Rover]

Duggie
Copps
Warboys

[Donnywolf]

Peter Kitchen

Paul Green

King Alick

[essexrover]

Glynn Snodin
Gary Brabin
Paul Green

[Avsuptem]

Big Brendan OCallaghan
Brian Deane
Stan Brookes
Rufus Brevit

Sorry, I can't count.

[philsky]

Very good question

1. Copps
2. Ian Snodin
3. Animal

Good to see Little get a mention !

[Padge_DRFC]

Bagayako
Bamogo
Goulon

[Swifty62]

Peter Kitchen
Brendan o'callaghan
Brian Usher

[Wokingviking]

Ian Miller
Alan Little
Michael McIndoe

[ForsolongaRover]

Very few still alive will have seen Peter Doherty, but not only did he have Coppinger-like skill, but he scored more than a goal every other game, and of course there was Alick, more dynamic, but surely seriously considered by everyone. Third place is difficult, but with the ability to seemingly score more than he missed, I’d go for Laurie Sheffield.