Vale Skylights

[ravenrover]

Maybe I should have been clearer and said the goal resulting from the penalty should not have been given
My question was what is the difference, is stopping in the run up classed as feinting or is it against the rules that is all. A number of  people seem to agree he stopped whether you agree or not, is stopping in your run up legal?  That is all I am querying

[scawsby steve]

Watched the whole match and never saw the fellow pass out

Apparently the girls in the ticket office passed out when they saw the photo of my boatrace that I sent in for my ST card last season.

[Bentley Bullet]

Watched the whole match and never saw the fellow pass out

Apparently the girls in the ticket office passed out when they saw the photo of my boatrace that I sent in for my ST card last season.

Maybe they thought Bela Lugosi was dead?

[rich1471]

The ref at the time shuck his head to say no penalty the 5-6 seconds later blows for it ,which was strange

[Goole Rover]

I once had my shirt pulled.
I fell backwards not flat forwards on my chest with my arms spread out

Bet it was Nodder Hodkin.

[RoversInSpain]

Not surprised it’s all confusing. However what I pick up from the rules is that during the run up the player can do what he likes. Seems that when his run is complete, the split second he’s about to kick the ball he cannot stop/feint/pass out etc.
Also the keeper is not allowed to distract the kicker in any way, even touching the bar /posts etc.Didnt know that.
But what I’m really waiting for is a back heel penalty….

[DonnyBazR0ver]

Not surprised it’s all confusing. However what I pick up from the rules is that during the run up the player can do what he likes. Seems that when his run is complete, the split second he’s about to kick the ball he cannot stop/feint/pass out etc.
Also the keeper is not allowed to distract the kicker in any way, even touching the bar /posts etc.Didnt know that.
But what I’m really waiting for is a back heel penalty….

Just to clarify about the Keeper. It doesn't say he can't distract the taker.

"The goalkeeper must not behave
in a way that unfairly distracts the kicker, e.g. delay the taking of the kick or touch the goalposts, crossbar or goal net"

He can FAIRLY distract the taker by such things as bouncing up and down, moving side to side, standing off centre etc etc. as long as he doesn't move forward of the line before the kicks taken (at least one foot on the line)

The taker can fairly stutter if he wants, and the keeper can fairly distract if he wants. Which is fair on both sides really.

[EasyforDennis]

Not surprised it’s all confusing. However what I pick up from the rules is that during the run up the player can do what he likes. Seems that when his run is complete, the split second he’s about to kick the ball he cannot stop/feint/pass out etc.
Also the keeper is not allowed to distract the kicker in any way, even touching the bar /posts etc.Didnt know that.
But what I’m really waiting for is a back heel penalty….

Just to clarify about the Keeper. It doesn't say he can't distract the taker.

"The goalkeeper must not behave
in a way that unfairly distracts the kicker, e.g. delay the taking of the kick or touch the goalposts, crossbar or goal net"

He can FAIRLY distract the taker by such things as bouncing up and down, moving side to side, standing off centre etc etc. as long as he doesn't move forward of the line before the kicks taken (at least one foot on the line)

The taker can fairly stutter if he wants, and the keeper can fairly distract if he wants. Which is fair on both sides really.

Clear as mud then. There is a point in a stutter when a person stops, albeit for a fraction of a second but nonetheless he still stops

[DonnyBazR0ver]

Not surprised it’s all confusing. However what I pick up from the rules is that during the run up the player can do what he likes. Seems that when his run is complete, the split second he’s about to kick the ball he cannot stop/feint/pass out etc.
Also the keeper is not allowed to distract the kicker in any way, even touching the bar /posts etc.Didnt know that.
But what I’m really waiting for is a back heel penalty….

Just to clarify about the Keeper. It doesn't say he can't distract the taker.

"The goalkeeper must not behave
in a way that unfairly distracts the kicker, e.g. delay the taking of the kick or touch the goalposts, crossbar or goal net"

He can FAIRLY distract the taker by such things as bouncing up and down, moving side to side, standing off centre etc etc. as long as he doesn't move forward of the line before the kicks taken (at least one foot on the line)

The taker can fairly stutter if he wants, and the keeper can fairly distract if he wants. Which is fair on both sides really.

Clear as mud then. There is a point in a stutter when a person stops, albeit for a fraction of a second but nonetheless he still stops

Which isn't illegal.