0 Members and 1 Guest are viewing this topic.
Quote from: DonnyNoel on April 01, 2019, 07:45:11 pmQuote from: bobbymax on April 01, 2019, 12:20:56 pmQuote from: Chris Black come back on April 01, 2019, 09:34:20 amIt Celtic played in English / fictional UK wide league, they would surely be a top half Premier League side most seasons easily. But they would not be winning league very often and would struggle to make Champions League. As a result they would be frozen out of big money. I've got be honest, I write a bit about Scottish football so have actually had to watch some of it over the last two seasons. The general standard is appalling and barely up to League 2 at times. The top three teams are better but nowhere near Premier League standard. Celtic and Rangers would both struggle to stay out of relegation trouble in most Championship seasons. Whilst the standard is certainly as you describe (albeit that makes it entertaining), put either Glasgow club in the English pyramid where they would benefit from English TV money then they'd be fine in the premiership. Club size will play a factor. There havent been many clubs of their size that have hit the third tier without taking into account serious financial ineptitude.I genuinely believe that, 20 years ago, when they were at their peak with experienced foreign internationals there, if both clubs had joined the Premier League then one of them would have been Champions League winners by now.Think of a never-ending support, due to religion, the fact they'd be isolated geographically in a 'British Premier League' and that they would sell-out crowds easily. That would have undoubtedly attracted investment around the same time as Roman Abramovich bought Chelsea and with the TV money going crazy since then, they'd have only got stronger on all fronts.Ifs, buts and maybes nowadays as they're a million miles off, but if they joined English football now they'd be in the top half of the Premier League within a decade. Maybe not top, but certainly no worse than Newcastle, Everton, etc.
Quote from: bobbymax on April 01, 2019, 12:20:56 pmQuote from: Chris Black come back on April 01, 2019, 09:34:20 amIt Celtic played in English / fictional UK wide league, they would surely be a top half Premier League side most seasons easily. But they would not be winning league very often and would struggle to make Champions League. As a result they would be frozen out of big money. I've got be honest, I write a bit about Scottish football so have actually had to watch some of it over the last two seasons. The general standard is appalling and barely up to League 2 at times. The top three teams are better but nowhere near Premier League standard. Celtic and Rangers would both struggle to stay out of relegation trouble in most Championship seasons. Whilst the standard is certainly as you describe (albeit that makes it entertaining), put either Glasgow club in the English pyramid where they would benefit from English TV money then they'd be fine in the premiership. Club size will play a factor. There havent been many clubs of their size that have hit the third tier without taking into account serious financial ineptitude.
Quote from: Chris Black come back on April 01, 2019, 09:34:20 amIt Celtic played in English / fictional UK wide league, they would surely be a top half Premier League side most seasons easily. But they would not be winning league very often and would struggle to make Champions League. As a result they would be frozen out of big money. I've got be honest, I write a bit about Scottish football so have actually had to watch some of it over the last two seasons. The general standard is appalling and barely up to League 2 at times. The top three teams are better but nowhere near Premier League standard. Celtic and Rangers would both struggle to stay out of relegation trouble in most Championship seasons.
It Celtic played in English / fictional UK wide league, they would surely be a top half Premier League side most seasons easily. But they would not be winning league very often and would struggle to make Champions League. As a result they would be frozen out of big money.