Alfie May !!

[since-1969]

On a hat trick , already scored 11 for the season !!

[sha66y]

That’s because he’s found his level….

[Petche]

Do we have to have this every time he scores? zzzzz

[since-1969]

That’s because he’s found his level….

yes , was he just too good for us ?

[sha66y]

Do we have to have this every time he scores? zzzzz

Probably…
and Whiteman just missed a penalty for Preston…lol

[since-1969]

Do we have to have this every time he scores? zzzzz

It’s about goal scorers .. we need one ?

[phil old leake]

11 goals could have put us in a safe pot

[scawsby steve]

11 goals could have put us in a safe pot

To even try and compare any of our strikers with Alfie is ludicrous.

He's light years ahead of any of them.

[DonnyBazR0ver]

Pathetic thread. We don't need reminding of the merits of Alfie May. Managers make decisions about players at the time.

End of.

[MachoMadness]

At the time it was the right decision to let him go. It's a sign of how far backwards we've gone that he looks like a world beater compared to what we've seen so far this season.

[scawsby steve]

Pathetic thread. We don't need reminding of the merits of Alfie May. Managers make decisions about players at the time.

End of.

No, but we need reminding about the merits of our strikers. F*cking useless.

[phil old leake]

It was never the right decision to let him go. Or rather sell him

Even as a sub he always gave 100%

[since-1969]

Pathetic thread. We don't need reminding of the merits of Alfie May. Managers make decisions about players at the time.

End of.

Your never too big to cry it’s ok !!

[elmsallrover]

11 goals could have put us in a safe pot

not if 4 of them where tonight where tonight

[Bentley Bullet]

An absolute bloody crying shame we got rid.

[Tommy A]

Based on most of our performances this year he would have had zero chances and therefore scored zero goals.

Most on here would have been calling for him to go.

In the position we were at when he was here he wasn't good enough to get a regular first team place. I don't recall a massive outcry when we let him go.

The fact that he may improve us now doesn't change the fact that it was right to let him go at the time.

[since-1969]

Based on most of our performances this year he would have had zero chances and therefore scored zero goals.

Most on here would have been calling for him to go.

In the position we were at when he was here he wasn't good enough to get a regular first team place. I don't recall a massive outcry when we let him go.

The fact that he may improve us now doesn't change the fact that it was right to let him go at the time.

Your forgetting he’ll be in L1 next year on a new two year contract !! Hayho !

[Tommy A]

Based on most of our performances this year he would have had zero chances and therefore scored zero goals.

Most on here would have been calling for him to go.

In the position we were at when he was here he wasn't good enough to get a regular first team place. I don't recall a massive outcry when we let him go.

The fact that he may improve us now doesn't change the fact that it was right to let him go at the time.

Your forgetting he’ll be in L1 next year on a new two year contract !! Hayho !

Not at all. It's a reflection on how badly things have gone here since he left.

[Bentley Bullet]

Based on most of our performances this year he would have had zero chances and therefore scored zero goals.

Most on here would have been calling for him to go.

In the position we were at when he was here he wasn't good enough to get a regular first team place. I don't recall a massive outcry when we let him go.

The fact that he may improve us now doesn't change the fact that it was right to let him go at the time.

The fact is it was wrong to let him go.

[DonnyBazR0ver]

Pathetic thread. We don't need reminding of the merits of Alfie May. Managers make decisions about players at the time.

End of.

Your never too big to cry it’s ok !!

Boo hoo!!

[Tommy A]

Based on most of our performances this year he would have had zero chances and therefore scored zero goals.

Most on here would have been calling for him to go.

In the position we were at when he was here he wasn't good enough to get a regular first team place. I don't recall a massive outcry when we let him go.

The fact that he may improve us now doesn't change the fact that it was right to let him go at the time.

The fact is it was wrong to let him go.

Not at the time IMO. We were looking towards the championship not middle to lower league 1.

Now Alfie almost equals ambition

[Bentley Bullet]

Based on most of our performances this year he would have had zero chances and therefore scored zero goals.

Most on here would have been calling for him to go.

In the position we were at when he was here he wasn't good enough to get a regular first team place. I don't recall a massive outcry when we let him go.

The fact that he may improve us now doesn't change the fact that it was right to let him go at the time.

The fact is it was wrong to let him go.

Not at the time IMO. We were looking towards the championship not middle to lower league 1.

Now Alfie almost equals ambition

Some said May wasn't League One standard. They were wrong, and we were wrong to let him go. He's too good for us now. We couldn't afford him.

[Sammy Chung was King]

At the time we could afford to let him go. He’s made a good job of improving himself while he’s been away. Our situation has been deteriorating for about three seasons. His enthusiasm would help our side but unfortunately we don’t have him.

There is potential in our strikers, they need opportunities otherwise they can’t do anything. Give Odubeko, Agard etc chances and they will score. Griffiths another one who has potential, get him fit and get him on .

[idler]

Just who exactly would be creating the chances for Alfie to score on what we have seen this season?
He wouldn't have got a look in last night against Rotherham, they were far too strong. When we let him go we were looking for better but unfortunately the whole team has gone downhill since then.

[Bentley Bullet]

We had more shots than Plymouth last Saturday. 24 to their 23. The chances were there, but the efforts were predictable and poor.

Alfie would very likely have been more effective.

[scunny rover]

Alfie may doesn't  play for doncaster rovers

[Bentley Bullet]

Alfie may doesn't  play for doncaster rovers

If he did there would be no point in the thread. However, he doesn't and some of us are expressing our regret at letting him go.

[scunny rover]

Max waters was better ,how far shall we go back?

[Bentley Bullet]

So was Billy Sharp, but we got a good payout for him.

[scunny rover]

Big alec