0 Members and 1 Guest are viewing this topic.
Are there strict rules, or is the club/player/club medical staff free to make a decision? There was clearly an official concussion substitute used on Tuesday. Is there a chance that if we play Woody tomorrow we could be penalised for using an illegal 4th window for a sub on Tuesday? Illegal player used usually means points deductions, or match replayed.
I don’t believe believe the medical staff would sacrifice the very essence of their profession just to ‘ field a side’ .
Quote from: Lazar on April 05, 2024, 06:34:15 amQuote from: Jimmydee on April 04, 2024, 07:45:38 pmI gave a young fan that was sat in front of me a bollocking for encouraging one of our players to ‘snap him’ , he said why can’t I say that, he’s the opposition?I said that it could end his promising career and also that he has a wife and young family at home, how would you feel if your dad got a serious disability injury at his workplace and couldn’t work anymore?I would also say the same if it was an older person that said it too.There’s absolutely zero chance you would say that to a big shithouse I’m sorry. But congratulations on being the moral arbiter of the home end. Must be nice on that moral high ground.How is correcting poor behaviour taking the moral high ground? Having met Jimmy I doubt the size of the person would dissuade him
Quote from: Jimmydee on April 04, 2024, 07:45:38 pmI gave a young fan that was sat in front of me a bollocking for encouraging one of our players to ‘snap him’ , he said why can’t I say that, he’s the opposition?I said that it could end his promising career and also that he has a wife and young family at home, how would you feel if your dad got a serious disability injury at his workplace and couldn’t work anymore?I would also say the same if it was an older person that said it too.There’s absolutely zero chance you would say that to a big shithouse I’m sorry. But congratulations on being the moral arbiter of the home end. Must be nice on that moral high ground.
I gave a young fan that was sat in front of me a bollocking for encouraging one of our players to ‘snap him’ , he said why can’t I say that, he’s the opposition?I said that it could end his promising career and also that he has a wife and young family at home, how would you feel if your dad got a serious disability injury at his workplace and couldn’t work anymore?I would also say the same if it was an older person that said it too.
Quote from: Dutch Uncle on April 05, 2024, 03:18:18 pmAre there strict rules, or is the club/player/club medical staff free to make a decision? There was clearly an official concussion substitute used on Tuesday. Is there a chance that if we play Woody tomorrow we could be penalised for using an illegal 4th window for a sub on Tuesday? Illegal player used usually means points deductions, or match replayed. I would imagine it’s indisputable that we made that substation in good faith. The question is then whether subsequent assessment identifies concussion. It’s down to the medical staff to make an assessment and I trust their judgement, but I’m surprised (if) he’s passed fit to play so soon.
Good news that he’s available but should players be playing in the same week they get a horrific bang on the head like he did. He stumbled off like a drunk.
That should be decided by the medical staff and the player not by some overriding political regulation especially from a Federation that is miles off the speed on most fronts .
Quote from: graingrover on April 05, 2024, 01:31:56 pmI don’t believe believe the medical staff would sacrifice the very essence of their profession just to ‘ field a side’ .Absolutely agree with this graingrover.Their professional integrity wouldn’t let that happen in my opinion.