Voting closes: February 14, 2026, 04:38:15 pm
Sven Vath and 1 Guest are viewing this topic.
Strange one. Is Grant actually in a stronger position if we get relegated? Who else would you want to build a promotion chasing team than someone who built a L2 title winning side last season?
I dont get this part of not recruited well.Just because every player hasn't blown the world apart.It's like you all expect each player to play to the top of their form every game and we then win promotion.
Do you mean league 1 player for hanlan?Crew, TLT, both excellent signings, that every supporter celebrated. The fact they haven’t worked out this time as well as the first time is surely down to the player. We know they’re both very good players who will no doubt play at a higher level than this. Crew especially seemed to turn up here with a poor attitude this season, It’s too early to suggest grehan is a bad signing for me, and I think Middleton, Gotts, o Riordan have been good signings, add to that haks, Clark, Byrne, Lee, Robinson I can’t see how this years recruitment can be described as poorly as people seem to be making out
Quote from: dickos1 on Today at 07:49:11 amDo you mean league 1 player for hanlan?Crew, TLT, both excellent signings, that every supporter celebrated. The fact they haven’t worked out this time as well as the first time is surely down to the player. We know they’re both very good players who will no doubt play at a higher level than this. Crew especially seemed to turn up here with a poor attitude this season, It’s too early to suggest grehan is a bad signing for me, and I think Middleton, Gotts, o Riordan have been good signings, add to that haks, Clark, Byrne, Lee, Robinson I can’t see how this years recruitment can be described as poorly as people seem to be making out I did mean that with Hanlan thanks, have corrected now.What supporters thought about Crew and TLT is totally irrelevant, they’ve proved to be poor signings and some of the responsibility of that has to sit with the people who signed them.The fact you say Middleton has been a good signing just shows that we see things completely differently. He’s hasn’t played much and when he has he has barely contributed. It’s not as though he’s being kept on the bench by someone playing out of their skin either, for the most part he’s been competing with an underwhelming Gibson. For me it’s mad to call him a “good signing”.
Quote from: NickDRFC on Today at 07:59:42 amQuote from: dickos1 on Today at 07:49:11 amDo you mean league 1 player for hanlan?Crew, TLT, both excellent signings, that every supporter celebrated. The fact they haven’t worked out this time as well as the first time is surely down to the player. We know they’re both very good players who will no doubt play at a higher level than this. Crew especially seemed to turn up here with a poor attitude this season, It’s too early to suggest grehan is a bad signing for me, and I think Middleton, Gotts, o Riordan have been good signings, add to that haks, Clark, Byrne, Lee, Robinson I can’t see how this years recruitment can be described as poorly as people seem to be making out I did mean that with Hanlan thanks, have corrected now.What supporters thought about Crew and TLT is totally irrelevant, they’ve proved to be poor signings and some of the responsibility of that has to sit with the people who signed them.The fact you say Middleton has been a good signing just shows that we see things completely differently. He’s hasn’t played much and when he has he has barely contributed. It’s not as though he’s being kept on the bench by someone playing out of their skin either, for the most part he’s been competing with an underwhelming Gibson. For me it’s mad to call him a “good signing”.How can you say they havent been good signing, they havent performed which is nothong to do with the recruitment team. We all would have signed those players.
Quote from: mpc123 on Today at 09:01:08 amQuote from: NickDRFC on Today at 07:59:42 amQuote from: dickos1 on Today at 07:49:11 amDo you mean league 1 player for hanlan?Crew, TLT, both excellent signings, that every supporter celebrated. The fact they haven’t worked out this time as well as the first time is surely down to the player. We know they’re both very good players who will no doubt play at a higher level than this. Crew especially seemed to turn up here with a poor attitude this season, It’s too early to suggest grehan is a bad signing for me, and I think Middleton, Gotts, o Riordan have been good signings, add to that haks, Clark, Byrne, Lee, Robinson I can’t see how this years recruitment can be described as poorly as people seem to be making out I did mean that with Hanlan thanks, have corrected now.What supporters thought about Crew and TLT is totally irrelevant, they’ve proved to be poor signings and some of the responsibility of that has to sit with the people who signed them.The fact you say Middleton has been a good signing just shows that we see things completely differently. He’s hasn’t played much and when he has he has barely contributed. It’s not as though he’s being kept on the bench by someone playing out of their skin either, for the most part he’s been competing with an underwhelming Gibson. For me it’s mad to call him a “good signing”.How can you say they havent been good signing, they havent performed which is nothong to do with the recruitment team. We all would have signed those players.Even if some of the players we recruited are good, just not performing, surely that lends itself to the fact that perhaps they don't fit into the managers system/style of play maybe. Thats all part of a poor recruitment process. No point signing good players that don't align with what you are trying to do on the pitch.
Can’t quite believe what I am reading. Nobody can be saying our summer recruitment wasn’t anything other than bad and being serious.
Quote from: Rupee92ONLY on Today at 09:15:49 amCan’t quite believe what I am reading. Nobody can be saying our summer recruitment wasn’t anything other than bad and being serious. I don't think it was bad at all, it looks bad now due to how the signings worked out but at the time 99% of fans were happy with them all.As mpc said, it boils down to fans thinking we have a god given right to be a great team in this league. Yes McCann hasn't helped with his ambition telling us he thinks we can push for the playoffs but he is hardly going to come out and say our squad isn't good enough and we will be in a relegation battle is he?Too many fifa and football manager experts these days, makes me wonder how they would've coped during the 1997/98 season had social media been around.
Not sure Grant is the issue. If the recruitment team think signing a Sharp like player who is short and doesnt want to head a ball for what is effectively a direct team alongside Middleton who would be perfect for a target man or larger forward who is good in the air like Ironside a few years ago then there is your issue.The disconnect between what Grant wants as a player versus what hes been given is miles apart. Even I know that he wants industrious wide forwards who are a goal threat, not an old-school winger getting to the byline and crossing it.He wants a Hanlan type, just a bit better. No coincedence that the physical Okoronkwo looked really good where he struggled at Lincoln... it's how we play. he needs players for the system.
This is Grant’s fourth season with us, in the first 3 we reached the play-off’s twice and won the league. This is by far the worst season (position wise) we have had under him as things stand at the present, so are we judging him on that? In regards to quality I can honestly say that in all those 3 previous seasons we weren’t that great before the January window so in that respect nothing has changed other than we haven’t kicked on as noticeably as we did in the previous 3.
Quote from: dickos1 on Today at 07:49:11 amDo you mean league 1 player for hanlan?Crew, TLT, both excellent signings, that every supporter celebrated. The fact they haven’t worked out this time as well as the first time is surely down to the player. We know they’re both very good players who will no doubt play at a higher level than this. Crew especially seemed to turn up here with a poor attitude this season, It’s too early to suggest grehan is a bad signing for me, and I think Middleton, Gotts, o Riordan have been good signings, add to that haks, Clark, Byrne, Lee, Robinson I can’t see how this years recruitment can be described as poorly as people seem to be making out We currently have one summer signing in our first choice XI. The summer recruitment was indeed poor.Signing Lee, Byrne, Clark, Haks isn't genius recruitment is it? They may be ok players but the talent identification part of the process isn't spectacular is it? Is signing 30+ year olds, that are likely past their best the route we go down long term?How can we improve the talent identification part of the recruitment process? How can we identify undervalued talent that will be able to help us punch above our weight long term? We are certainly punching below our weight at the minute and thats largely down to not having a functioning recruitment setup.What is our edge over other teams when it comes to recruiting? What are we doing better than the rest?
Quote from: Fal on Today at 10:01:59 amQuote from: Rupee92ONLY on Today at 09:15:49 amCan’t quite believe what I am reading. Nobody can be saying our summer recruitment wasn’t anything other than bad and being serious. I don't think it was bad at all, it looks bad now due to how the signings worked out but at the time 99% of fans were happy with them all.As mpc said, it boils down to fans thinking we have a god given right to be a great team in this league. Yes McCann hasn't helped with his ambition telling us he thinks we can push for the playoffs but he is hardly going to come out and say our squad isn't good enough and we will be in a relegation battle is he?Too many fifa and football manager experts these days, makes me wonder how they would've coped during the 1997/98 season had social media been around.Surely recruitment gets judged on how signings work out? Isn't that the best way to assess it?I'm only interested in process, do i think our process can be improved? yes.
Quote from: GazLaz on Today at 10:10:50 amQuote from: Fal on Today at 10:01:59 amQuote from: Rupee92ONLY on Today at 09:15:49 amCan’t quite believe what I am reading. Nobody can be saying our summer recruitment wasn’t anything other than bad and being serious. I don't think it was bad at all, it looks bad now due to how the signings worked out but at the time 99% of fans were happy with them all.As mpc said, it boils down to fans thinking we have a god given right to be a great team in this league. Yes McCann hasn't helped with his ambition telling us he thinks we can push for the playoffs but he is hardly going to come out and say our squad isn't good enough and we will be in a relegation battle is he?Too many fifa and football manager experts these days, makes me wonder how they would've coped during the 1997/98 season had social media been around.Surely recruitment gets judged on how signings work out? Isn't that the best way to assess it?I'm only interested in process, do i think our process can be improved? yes.The best team in the world needs improvement, that never stops. As a club we have limited funds, there is only so much progress a year you can do. We are taking all the right steps under an agreed budget, we cannot ask for more than that.
Hindsight is a wonderful thing isn't it?I for one was pretty well pleased with our summer recruitment based on where we stand as a club and the budget we have available, has it turns out some of the comments from fans of their previous clubs turned out to be not far from the mark on their short comings and on the whole I don't think anybody can argue it's been a disappointment.That said the area I would be questioning more than recruitment is the actual coaching of the players. We don't seem to have any variety in our set pieces whether it's free kicks or corners and when we are defending them we are often guilty of not been switched on getting away with it, only to concede in the same situation later in the gameMaybe we have rose tinted spectacles but you look at our midfield of Ads,Bails,Mols,broadbent,clifton and Middleton and you think that has to be a superior league 1 midfield for controlling the game and the ball based on their individual talents yet the stats suggest we have inferior possession compared to the opposition more times than not so for me either they are not as good as we think or the shape and coaching is not good enough.That might be down to GM's attacking philosophy but you can hardly say that's as entertaining to watch as it sounds. As for GM himself my biggest moan with him is his bloody reluctance to throw his hat behind an out and out striker like Billy was. He just goes for utility forward players who can play anywhere up top but those type of players are never going to trouble the goal scoring charts.